You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Thu, Oct 13, 2011 : 7:08 p.m.

Can Brady Hoke do what a Michigan coach hasn't done since 1948?

By Pete Cunningham

Oosterbaan_Elliott.jpg

Benny Oosterbaan, left, poses with assistant Bump Elliott before the 1958 season. Oosterbaan, who was the last Michigan coach to beat Michigan State in his first try, retired after that season and was replaced by Elliott, who lost 34-8 to the Spartans in 1959.

File photo

Bump Elliott couldn't do it. Neither could Bo Schembechler, Gary Moeller, Lloyd Carr or Rich Rodriguez.

On Saturday, current Michigan football coach Brady Hoke will attempt to do something that none of his predecessors have done since 1948 -- beat Michigan State in his first year in charge of the Wolverines.

It's a feat last accomplished by Bennie Oosterbaan, who led Michigan to a win over the Spartans on the way to a 1948 national title.

Here's a look into The Ann Arbor News archives to reveal some details from that 1948 game, and from every Michigan-Michigan State game since that included a first-year coach on the Michigan sideline:

BENNIE OOSTERBAAN

Date: September 25, 1948.

Location: East Lansing.

Score: Michigan 13, Michigan State 7

BennieOosterbaan_File.jpg

Bennie Oosterbaan

File photo

The game was also the head coaching debut for Oosterbaan, who took over for Fritz Crisler. Though he'd become the only Michigan coach in the modern era to defeat Michigan State in his first go-around, the feeling at the time was that Michigan greatly underperformed in the game after beating Spartans by 55- and 48-point margins the previous two years. The Thursday, Sept. 23, edition of The Ann Arbor News proclaimed the Wolverines favorites by “three or four touchdowns.”

But it took a fourth quarter, “two-and-a-half” yard run from Michigan fullback Tom Peterson to break a 7-7 tie in the second half and put Michigan ahead for good. The game story described the Wolverines as having “no zip.”

Oosterbaan’s backfield coach, George Ceithaml, wasn’t pleased with Michigan’s showing. “We can’t make that many mistakes and hope to win again,” he said

Michigan finished the season 9-0 and won its second consecutive national championship while Michigan State finished the year 6-2-2.

Sign of the times: The Sept. 25 game was the season opener. By the same time this year, the Wolverines were 4-0.

On that same day: The Michigan Civil Rights Federation was one of 82 organizations nationally declared as “communist” by attorney general Tom C. Clark.


BUMP ELLIOTT

Date: October 3, 1959.

Location: Ann Arbor.

Score: Michigan State 34, Michigan 8

BumpElliott_Sideline.jpg

Bump Elliott, shown yelling to his team during a 24-17 win at Michigan State in 1960, wasn't as fortunate in 1959.

File photo

With both teams trying to avoid an 0-2 start, the favored Spartans traveled to Ann Arbor to take on the Wolverines.

Not everyone who made the trip was welcomed with open arms. The night before the game, a mob of Michigan students surrounded a car with Michigan State emblems in the window, covered it in yellow paint and shaving cream, then deflated the tires.

It was the Wolverines who appeared deflated on the field, though. Michigan State scored the game’s first 34 points, scoring on three of its first four possessions. Michigan scored its only touchdown on a fourth quarter run by quarterback Stan Noskin.

“The Wolverines’ one moment of triumph came before the first kickoff when they won the pre-game coin toss,” wrote News reporter Dave Tefft.

Michigan finished the season 4-5, Michigan State 5-4.

Sign of the times: Michigan State’s travel roster consisted of 38 players in 1959. Michigan’s travel roster on Saturday will be close to 80.

On the same day: The Soviet Union prepared to launch Luna 3, the third spacecraft successfully launched to the Moon. The probe would be launched the Sunday morning following the game and take the first ever photos of the the far side of the moon on Oct. 7.


BO SCHEMBECHLER

Date: October 18, 1969.

Location: East Lansing.

Score: Michigan State 23, Michigan 12

Schembechler_Carry.jpg

Bo Schembechler would be carried off the field later in 1969, but not after his first game against the Spartans.

File photo

Michigan was favored in the contest, but it was the Spartans who took advantage of a windy day in East Lansing by keeping the ball on the ground. Though Michigan State had been employing a triple option to that point in the season, the Spartans used a power-I and compiled 348 yards on the ground.

“Three hundred and forty eight yards rushing?” first-year coach Bo Schembechler rhetorically asked reporters after the game. “That’s terrible. We can’t ever win football games giving up 348 yards.”

Michigan State quarterback Bill Triplett rushed for 142 yards on 18 carries and was voted offensive MVP by his teammates. Michigan’s offense was largely ineffective most of the game.

“It was hard to throw against that wind,” Michigan State coach Duffy Daugherty told reporters.

Michigan finished the season 8-3, Michigan State 4-6.

Signs of the times: The game was not televised. The University of Michigan aired a closed circuit broadcast at the University Events Building, charging $2 and $3 for admission. ... After Michigan State scored to go up 14-3, Glenn Doughty fielded the ensuing kickoff for Michigan at the 1-yard line, but accidentally stepped into the end zone. That, at the time, was an automatic safety.

On that same day: Fourteen black football players were kicked off the undefeated University of Wyoming football team hours before a game against Brigham Young University. Later coined the “Black 14,” the players were dismissed for wearing black armbands in support of a protest by Wyoming Black Student Alliance against BYU’s “racial policies.” Among those dismissed were Battle Creek native Tony McGee, who went on to play 14 seasons in the NFL.


GARY MOELLER

Date: October 13, 1990.

Location: Ann Arbor.

Score: Michigan State 28, Michigan 27

The non-call heard 'round the (college football) world. Michigan State led 28-21 with less than 2 minutes to play when Michigan quarterback Elvis Grbac led the Wolverines on a 71-yard drive capped by a Derrick Alexander touchdown reception with 6 seconds remaining.

Moeller_Headset.jpg

Gary Moeller

File photo

With no overtime in college football at the time, Moehler decided to go for a two-point conversion and the win. Though Grbac hit a diving Desmond Howard in the end zone, Howard dropped the ball. Replays show Howard being held, then tripped by Michigan State cornerback Eddie Brown on the play -- but they also show the ball hitting off of Howard’s chest and hands.

“I was surprised there was no flag,” Brown told reporters after the game.

“I’m not going to question the referee’s call,” said Howard. “He did what he thought was right.”

Michigan finished the season 9-3, Michigan State 8-3-1.

Sign of the times: Michigan entered the game ranked No. 1 in the nation despite losing its season opener to Notre Dame.

On that same day: The Pittsburgh Pirates -- coached by Jim Leyland -- packed up their clubhouse after having their season end the night before with a loss in Game 6 of the National League Championship.


LLOYD CARR

Date: November 4, 1995.

Carr_Hoke_Sideline.jpg

Lloyd Carr (with a familiar-looking assistant coach in 2002) went 10-3 against the Spartans, but started the rivalry with a 1995 loss.

File photo

Location: East Lansing.

Score: Michigan State 28, Michigan 25

Both teams featured first-year head coaches as Nick Saban had just taken over for George Perles in East Lansing. No. 7 ranked Michigan was favored heading into the contest against unranked Michigan State.

Spartans quarterback Tony Banks threw for a career high 318 yards and hit Nigea Carter for the game-winning touchdown with 1:24 left in the game. Michigan had trailed by 11 points at halftime.

“We had our opportunities, to win. Michigan State made the plays it needed to win, we didn’t,” Carr told reporters after the game

Michigan State players carried Saban off the field on their shoulders.

Michigan finished the season 9-4, Michigan State 6-5-1.

Sign of the times: News writer Dean Howe called the Michigan State win the “biggest in the brief college coaching career of Nick Saban” and told Spartans fans to “get ready for a bright future,” under Saban.

On that same day: Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated in Tel Aviv.


RICH RODRIGUEZ

Date: October 25, 2008.

Location: Ann Arbor

Score: Michigan State 35, Michigan 21

Rodriguez_Dantonio.JPG

Rich Rodriguez was winless against Michigan State's Mark Dantonio, left, in his three seasons as Michigan's head coach.

The score was tied after every quarter but the one that mattered most after the Spartans outscored Michigan 14-0 in the fourth quarter. Michigan trailed by seven in each of the first two quarters, but Brandon Minor touchdowns in each leveled the score.

Michigan briefly led, 21-14, in the third quarter after quarterback Steven Threet rushed in from 2 yards out, but Michigan State ended the game by scoring 21 unanswered.

Michigan’s junior defensive end Brandon Graham -- now with the Philadelphia Eagles -- guaranteed a Michigan win before the game.

"I feel confident that my team had my back when I guaranteed the win. I am not going to take it back. I still believe we should have won the game," Graham said after the loss.

Michigan went on to finish the season 3-9, its first losing season since 1967. Michigan State finished 9-4.

Sign of the times: Michigan’s starting quarterback and co-leading rusher from the game -- Threet and Sam McGuffie -- weren’t on the team the following year. Threet transferred to Arizona State, McGuffie to Rice.

On that same day: The Wisconsin football team ended its four-game losing streak with a 27-17 win over Illinois. The skid had been the Badgers' longest in 12 years.


Contact Pete Cunningham at petercunningham@annarbor.com or by phone at 734-623-2561. Follow him on Twitter @petcunningham.

Comments

Eric

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 5:43 p.m.

Not that I want to build expectations that are already growing steadily beyond reality, but... Hoke is a solid coach with a proven track record in multiple places. Hoke knows how to manage the Michigan fan base, because he's "one of us." Hoke is doing things "the right way." You break the rules, you pay the price, and you'll actually sit. Hoke is focused on helping young men to become better men. The man's got his heart and his attention in the right place. These kids, no doubt, would jump off a bridge if Coach Hoke said so. He's winning minds and hearts by being a fantastic leader, whether that's his intent or not, and I see a prolific Michigan career ahead of him, regardless of what this first MSU game brings. Praise be to HOKE! GO BLUE! (ok - so I admittedly may be a victim of my own over-inflated expectations. crap)

MRunner73

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 5:21 p.m.

Admiration grows for Coach Hoke and staff on the improvements they made to this Michigan football team. Coach Hoke obviously understands the meaning of this rivalry. Going into to this game, it is good to see both U of M and MSU programs on equal ground. The team that wants it the most will win and I do not under estimate the Brady Hoke led football team. Being an assistent here helps but it not so when Moeller and Carr took over the head coaching duties in their first MSU game. So, I think that Hoke has a very good chance to pull this off. GO BLUE!!!

zeeba

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 4:53 p.m.

No.

1st Down

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 4:12 a.m.

Here is a clip of young M coach Bump Eliott and his brother Pete Eliott on &quot;Whats My Line&quot; circa 1961 <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vc3BwjSLFXM" rel='nofollow'>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vc3BwjSLFXM</a>

Rufus

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 6:01 a.m.

That was great. thank for posting the clip.

1st Down

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 4:10 a.m.

Numbers on the helmets....+ a 31 game edge over sparty = another win on Saturday for Blue

al

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 3:15 a.m.

I thought the answer to the question was going to be &quot;have a black quarterback&quot;

Randy Savage

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 1:42 a.m.

Two of the greatest champions with the greatest uniforms aligning for world domination. Michigan will beat State just I like I beat Hogan. Go Blue! Oh yeeeeah!

Tru2Blu76

Fri, Oct 14, 2011 : 12:52 a.m.

Thanks Pete, for bringing this Michigan history to us. But this history certainly gives fans a chill. Why: Bump Elliot previously held the modern record as &quot;worst head coach&quot; at Michigan. But he started his 10 year HC career as one of Michigan's finest players who everyone thought highly of. He had solid coaching experience so everyone expected he'd be great. It wasn't his first-year loss to MSU that did him in, it was his .547 career record capped by a lopsided loss to OSU on 1968 that did him in. Elliott was: a prototypical &quot;Michigan Man.&quot; Now we have a new coach off to a credible start who is also: a prototypical Michigan Man. I just don't want a loss to MSU to become Hoke's &quot;Michigan Man Curse.&quot; Like Elliott: there's no sign at all something bad could happen. In that way, I can't wait to see the end of this season because I think it will foretell whether Brady Hoke is the next Bump Elliott. (BTW: Elliot resigned and went on to become AD at Iowa, where he presided over a huge turnaround in Iowa's program which lasted a couple of decades.) Snap the curse, Brady Hoke! Go Blue!

tim

Thu, Oct 13, 2011 : 9:37 p.m.

Too bad for State that all bad things must come to an end , go blue!