Don't read too much into the Michigan - or anyone else's - spring game
Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson just threaded another pass for a touchdown. The fans cheered. The media scribbled notes. Points - arbitrary as they were during the Michigan football team’s game Saturday afternoon - were awarded.
Not trying to put a damper on things here, but what some 35,000 fans saw on a cold, blustery day at Michigan Stadium didn’t add up to much.
Was Robinson, who was clearly the offensive star of the day, really that good? Or was it because he played virtually all of his snaps against Michigan’s second-team defense on a day where the offensive and defensive first teams didn’t line up against each other?
So to glean anything out of Saturday is tough at best and silly at worst. To make assumptions off of one practice - and really, that’s what fans saw Saturday - is borderline silly.
The quarterback competition, as Michigan coach Rich Rodriguez said after the scrimmage, is wide open. Same at running back and almost everywhere else.
Bits and pieces can be discerned - for instance, Michigan is in real trouble kicking and punting - but let's avoid any sweeping proclamations about this team.
For the Michigan players and coaches, not much changed from what happens multiple times a week outside Schembechler Hall. Perhaps, it was even less informative than a normal practice, especially the way the Wolverines ran it. There was very little trickery - just a Tate Forcier pooch punt that Michigan has shown in games before - and the offense and defensive schemes were vanilla.
Players shuffled in and out, getting more repetitions and, save for the freshman or sophomore who hadn’t played in front of a big crowd before, it is a lot like another practice.
That’s not a criticism. That’s expected.
The biggest bonus, at least from what Rodriguez hinted, was what the players showed without constant coaching on the field.
Saturday was about Michigan’s fans. They could watch practice for free - better than at Florida and Notre Dame, which charge money for the event - and it became one giant pep rally with football plays.
Again, not surprising.
Hence the good cause breaks in play to introduce children from the Mott Children’s Hospital, which gained $300,000 in donations Saturday. Or that the band, at times, played throughout extra points and plays.
But what can be really read out of it? Well, ask one of Michigan’s players. “Uh, really, um ,” safety Vladimir Emilien said. “Yeah, we try to play our butts off. We don’t want to make ourselves look like fools.
“Everybody plays their butt off no matter what, but come August, you’re going to see the real deal.”
In August, a lot will look different. For Michigan’s sake, it better.
As good as Robinson and wide receiver Roy Roundtree and linebacker Obi Ezeh looked, much of what Michigan did wasn’t the crispest.
After 15 practices, it shouldn’t. Rodriguez said as much. He saw positives. And he saw things that need work.
“Probably not as many answers as I would like to have,” Rodriguez said. “But probably as many as you’d normally expect. Mostly positive. A few concerns, but every coach in America will probably tell you at the end of spring they have a few concerns.
“I have a few, but I feel a lot more positives.”
In other words, don’t get too excited or upset yet. About anything.
There’s a long, long way to go.
Michael Rothstein covers University of Michigan sports for AnnArbor.com. He can be reached at (734) 623-2558, by e-mail at michaelrothstein@annarbor.com or follow along on Twitter @mikerothstein.
Comments
Sean T.
Mon, Apr 19, 2010 : 9:03 a.m.
True fact is Denard is improved but he played against the number 2 defense while Forcier played against the number 1 defense. I believe Tate will be the starter by Sept 4th.
Opalmerr
Sun, Apr 18, 2010 : 9:29 a.m.
The most disappointing aspect of yesterday's spring "game" was the continued lack of physical play. This spread offense is all about finesse and is lacking a power running game. The defense practices against the spread everyday and will be woefully unprepared to play power teams in the Big 10. I had hoped to see indications that this team was ready to become competitive in the Big 10 once again but instead came away realizing that the days when "Defense wins championships" are long gone and the only way we can hope the Wolverines will be even.500 is if they can average 40 points a game.
Terry Star21
Sat, Apr 17, 2010 : 8:52 p.m.
So that works two ways right? The fact that it was a just spring game shouldn't mean too much right? I am relieved because I didn't see a lot from the 'D', but now I feel better. Once the freshman 'D' arrives this summer and challenges the vet's, the defense will start taking shape - gonna be a good fall season for the Michigan 'D'. 'Borderline Silly'... why do outsiders always ask us why our own media hate's our team. I didn't see anyone at the game today saying/thinking, '... what we saw didn't add up to much...silly at worst...'. So 'borderline silly', maybe that was the above story I just read, makes sense...
BowlForBlue
Sat, Apr 17, 2010 : 8:02 p.m.
That's correct, it's a spring game... however, the fact remains that Denard showed improved, yes vastly improved skills at his passing game - precision passing, scrambling, and decision making.... everything he failed at last season... final point is, with the improvement shown, look for Denard to start.
johnnya2
Sat, Apr 17, 2010 : 7:53 p.m.
Fresh, Sounds like you are setting up the ideal scenario for RR. I played the best QB, but it is his first year starting. Improvement is when you play well in a GAME, not in a scrimmage or practice. Robinson would have had to been horrible to play worse than he did last season.
Fresh121
Sat, Apr 17, 2010 : 6:25 p.m.
Michael 1 thing we can take away is denard has made strides in bein a QB not just to run..anyone that doesent think denard is night and day arent watching very well, Tate either had a off day or is still alittle hurt, but hes still making dumb plays, you cant say just cuz shoelace played against the 2s doesent mean he dident show alot more. Denard will be the starter he brings more weapons then tate and when this kid can pass like a top 3 qb in the BT its gonna be fun to watch.