Birk's Eye View: Brandon Minor makes a huge difference, plus other notes from Michigan's upset win
Michigan's offense is a different animal when Brandon Minor’s on the field.
Minor ran for 106 yards and a touchdown in Saturday’s 38-34 win over Notre Dame, giving the Wolverines the between-the-tackles presence they lacked a week earlier when Minor missed the Western Michigan game with a sprained ankle.
"That's just me," Minor said. "The physical style of play, I like to hit. If somebody’s going to tackle me, they got to pay for it."
Minor, who played at less than 100 percent Saturday, scored Michigan's first touchdown on a 2-yard plunge and set up another score with a beast of a third quarter.
He carried eight times for 70 yards in the period, and had gains of 16 and 32 yards on his first two runs.
While Michigan's spread offense relies primarily on speed, Minor's destructive style adds an interesting dimension. He's the Wolverines' most complete back, a tone-setter, and they need him healthy to contend in the still-rugged Big Ten.
"I don’t know if you noticed how physical Brandon was blocking, and Carlos (Brown), on all those blitzes," Michigan coach Rich Rodriguez said. "It was something neat to watch."
Positives, negatives and leftovers
Let’s close the book on Notre Dame before moving on to Eastern Michigan. Michigan still has its flaws, including in the secondary, where the Wolverines could be in for some long days, especially if Mike Williams’ leg injury is serious. But there were more plusses than minuses Saturday.
The good
• Walk-on safety Jordan Kovacs played well in place of Williams, who grabbed at the back of his right leg while chasing Notre Dame tight end Kyle Rudolph on a long pass that was called back late in the third quarter. Kovacs, who had three tackles, presumably gets the start next week against Eastern if Williams can’t play.
“Here it is in crunch time, the second half of the game, they’ve got some of their four- and five-star (players in) - and they’re really good players,” Rodriguez said. “And then we got Jordan Kovacs, who was a school-start walk-on, second time. First time he didn’t make it because he was injured and he went and got his knee fixed. We told him to come back again to try out with the general student body, and not only does he try out and make the team, now he’s in there playing at safety, in the middle of crunch time, national TV, against Notre Dame. To me, that’s pretty special.”
• Kind of lost in the dramatics of Saturday - I know I neglected to mention it anywhere - was the great quick kick Michigan called for on a fourth-and-2 near midfield late in the third quarter.
First, quarterback Tate Forcier made a great punt (50 yards) on a play that caught Notre Dame off guard. Second, Darryl Stonum had the hustle play of the day, lunging to tap the ball clear of the goal line, where Greg Mathews touched it dead at the 4. The whole sequence changed field position at a very important stage of the game.
• After allowing 302 yards of offense in the first half, Michigan’s defense held Notre Dame to just 188 yards in the second. It helped that the offense was on the field longer - remember, Stonum took a kick back for a touchdown early - but Michigan also made a few defensive corrections.
“We were hitting them with the right, they were going left, so it was just a matter of us switching it up, mixing it up a little bit,” cornerback Donovan Warren said.
The bad
• My own two cents: That was a weak taunting call, for shushing the crowd, on Notre Dame running back Armando Allen after his two-point conversion gave the Irish a 34-31 lead with 5:13 to play. Because of the 15-yard penalty, Notre Dame had to kick off from the 15-yard line. It doesn’t taint the win, but field judge Gerald Hocker should have kept the flag in his pocket there, or at least warned Allen to be careful with his celebration - like Greg Mathews said an official did for him after scoring the game-winning touchdown.
• Kicker Jason Olesnavage drilled a 39-yard field goal to end the first half, but missed a chip-shot 26-yarder in the third quarter. Worst of all, the miss came after Michigan took a delay-of-game penalty to get a better angle.
• As good as Michael Floyd and Golden Tate are - and they’re the best receivers Michigan will face all year - I still have doubts about the Wolverines secondary. Of course, no sacks doesn’t help matters, either.
The extras
• Rodriguez’s father, Vince, said the past few weeks, including allegations of NCAA violations, have been “rough on (Rodriguez), rough on his family.” “It meant the world to him, this game,” Vince Rodriguez said.
• Mathews said he “misread the coverage” on Forcier’s fourth-quarter interception, the first turnover of the young quarterback’s career. “It was definitely my fault,” he said. “Just after that happened I felt bad. I knew I had to definitely make up for it and I just didn’t want to think of sitting in the locker room and just having to go through just what I’ve been through and that happening and then I make a mistake like that to lose the game, so I definitely wanted to atone for that mistake.”
Atone he did, of course, with that game-winning 5-yard touchdown catch.
Comments
Jon
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 2:35 p.m.
RR should look at some of the running back talent in the Inland Empire of So. Cal, and the Antelope Valley. He can snipe some of that talent from Pete carroll. I knoww RR is a great recruiter and he has a pipeline set up going into the sunshine state, but don't forget about the bumper crop of running backs in southern california. RR is doing a masterful job and I have been in his corner all along. Two years from now we will all be watching him and the athletes wearing maize and blue raise the crytal football against some hapless victim......
wolver4ever
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 1:25 p.m.
You are correct the unsportsman pentaly should have been on #7 not #5. Clausen was doing a dance and point at one of the Michigan players. The offical got the number wrong
81wolverine
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 11:22 a.m.
I agree 100% with your comments on Brandon Minor. He NEEDS to stay healthy and be on the field for Michigan to have a successful running game. He's our best, most experienced back who seems to know how to find holes in the line. His spark got Michigan back in the game in the 2nd half. I'm pretty sure the taunting call you mentioned was on the ND QB Clausen, not Armando Allen. Clausen was sitting on the field doing a sort of "victory dance" while pointing at a Michigan defender. Not good judgement by him at all.
EricS
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 9:26 a.m.
Weak coverage. I was expecting a lot more about Brandon Minor. On top of that, after 2 days, it's very, very hard to find decent coverage of the game. Sad to see what Ann Arbor News has morphed into.
michboy40
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 9:25 a.m.
Michigan is not there yet, because of inexperience and lack of depth, but that was an amazing win and Michigan is on it's way to being dominant!
ohiowolverine
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 8:31 a.m.
Stevieboy, I agree with your coment about the secondry being weak but like you said they will improve with each week. Every win this year will be special but I'm looking forward to the next couple of years when Michigan will be unstopable. GO BLUE FOREVER!
stevieboy
Mon, Sep 14, 2009 : 1:50 a.m.
Minor is a BEAST when he runs the ball. He is definitely needed in this offense. You need a physical back to counter a physical team and that's what he did. Yes our secondary is weak, but RR and the staff has known that all along. That will change in the next few years with recruiting. But the good thing is these are not weak DB's that Michigan have, they are inexperienced. It was good for them to go against some primetime receivers like ND's and find out what they need to work on. They are only going to get better with trial and error by playing, not on the sideline. They will get better later on this year and will be at the status to challenge quality WR. I don't see a need for panic. Plus coach Rob put a defensive scheme together late in the came to contain the big play. It takes a team effort in all aspects of the game to win. Michigan won because of TEAM play.
tater
Sun, Sep 13, 2009 : 9:24 p.m.
Not only was the taunting call deserved, they should have gotten one on the guy who scored in the right corner when he slowed down and held the ball out. Holier-than-thou Notre Dame should be above that kind of behavior. I'm sure the old-timers there are mortified and will be calling for Weis' head, as long as they don't have to try and carry the rest of him.
Txmaizenblue
Sun, Sep 13, 2009 : 9:23 p.m.
Minor reminds me of a larger version of Mike Hart. He runs with authority. I agree with you Birkett - the secondary scares me. ND should have won that game. I think Weis blew it by trying too many game breaker passes. He could have picked and plucked his way down the field...go figure - that's why ND is what they've been the last 5 years. I'm glad they did not though, because Tate Forcier deserved to win that game. BIRKETT: Please somebody post something about Robinson's inexplicable game plan!! For crying out loud - almost every time he put pressure on Clausen it ended up as an incompletion or a loss or short gain! EVERY TIME HE RUSHED 3 GUYS NOTRE DAME ATE UP THE FIELD. I was going crazy. Why stop doing something that works? It almost seemed like his defensive calls were scripted instead of game flow driven.
jimb
Sun, Sep 13, 2009 : 6:29 p.m.
On TV it looked as though Stonum was hurt before he was replaced on the field. Are there any reports about his injury?
tulsatom
Sun, Sep 13, 2009 : 5:32 p.m.
Nice article. Minor definitely is "major" to the success of this team. Also, thanks for clarifying what happened on the interception. I had assumed it was Forcier's fault but Mathews said it was on him. He definitely atoned for it with a nice grab for the winning TD. Listening to Lou (Golden Dome) Holtz's subdued tone on ESPN was "Must See TV" entertainment after the game. For an analyst, he does ok on games not involving Notre Dame but has an obvious bias in favor of ND and does little to hide it.