Has your decision to adopt a pitbull been derailed because of pressure from others?
flickr photo courtesy of mccoy77
There is a huge dichotomy when it comes to buying a pet from a breeder versus adopting a pet — and from there, a further decision is where to adopt from: a rescue or shelter? Needless to say, there is a a huge movement among animal lovers urging potential pet owners to "adopt, don't shop,",and that's a good thing.
It's a fact that there are simply too many homeless animals of all species (mainly dogs, cats, bunnies and the like), and in many cases, it's not just that these creatures don't have stable homes: we are continually working against their biology in many ways.
You see, we've invited them to live side by side with us in our homes. They are dependent on us for their basic needs, not limited to shelter, food and daily care but also their overall welfare, including good curation of their respective breeds as well as respect for their natural instincts and not trying to reign in their nature.
Pets also depend on us to get as handle on their reproduction. Respecting each breed (appropriate training methods, having a great understanding of the breed's behavior and needs) and good spay and neuter programs are crucial because they help hurdle the huge stumbling block that I referenced earlier — a battle against their most basic biology.
Animals are programmed by nature to keep the species alive and well, period. That means that they need to reproduce in mass quantities to do so and adapt stategies to cope with difficult situations. The latter is the focus of what I am getting at, and how it has tainted our view of shelter dogs, and one demographic in particular: pit bulls.
Ah, yes... the much maligned pit bull. It's no secret that this dog has been the topic of many blogs and articles throughout the region. Whether you refer to them as bully breeds, bullies, pit bulls... it really doesn't matter.
We humans have tried to mold dogs, in general, into things that they are not. For some ruthless and ill-meaning individuals, they use the qualities of a dog to serve their own needs (the American Kennel Club is guilty of this as well, with its penchant for creating the best-looking dog, but I'll leave them out of this piece), and in the process, these people tamper with the behavior, the breeds that comprise the term "pit bull" and, eventually, the legacy of these innocent pooches.
Because of that, dogs put in situations that are less-than-savory have had to resort to survival techniques that ensure their well-being. We don't see the majority of those, save for reports of attacks and dog fighting ring busts. Sadly, the term "pit bull," for many, is synonymous with viciousness, behavior problems and dog bite incidents.
Adoptable shelter dogs in many people's eyes are considered throwaways, damaged, and have been "someone else's problem, so that's why they are there" — or other nonsense like that.
The shelters of today make sure that the dogs that they deem as adoptable meet specific criteria. They work hard to match appropriate homes with each dog (even in fostering programs), and their track record is superb.
This includes pit bulls. But they are stigmatized.
The issue of shelter pets — and more importantly, pitbulls that are waiting to be adopted — along with a conversation I had a few months ago has had me thinking about an interesting dilemma a friend faced. T
he conversation centered around a friend being ready to adopt a dog after losing their previous dog weeks earlier. Upon visiting their local shelter, a pit bull puppy caught their eye; for many reasons, the dog seemed to be a great fit for them.
An experienced dog owner of several breeds, they decided to forgo adopting the puppy after realizing how polarizing the situation would be: family and friends made it clear that they would not welcome the dog into their homes. My friend wasn't sure how well the dog would be accepted if they were to bring the dog into the workplace.
With their previous canine companion, that had never been an issue.
With dogs being so very much a part of our social culture as well as our home lives, and the obvious stigma attached to pitbulls, I'm sure that this isn't an isolated thing.
If you've considered the prospect of adopting a shelter dog, has a pit bull been a candidate either by chance because they seemed like a great fit for your family, or by intent — but have you then decided to forgo the idea because of pressure from family, friends and society?
Participate in the poll and interact with your comments below.
Lorrie Shaw is lead pets blogger for AnnArbor.com and writes about pet health, behavior, pet culture and more. Catch her daily adventures as a dog walker and pet sitter or email her directly.
Comments
BobbyJohn
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 6:32 p.m.
Has noone noticed another person just recently killed in Michigan by their own Pit Bull. Of course they can be sweet and lovable, but when they are not, the tremendous strength of their jaws make them too much of a threat to human life. It IS the state to cities job to protect human life
Lorrie Shaw
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 8:54 p.m.
Surely any canine that is known to be vicious should not be able to harm anyone. But what I am discussing in this post are not dogs that are in that category. Many breeds can fit in that scenario. What I am focusing on, are dogs that are vetted for sound behavior/temprament, are healthy - and determined to be adoptable. Are you saying that these dogs do not have a place in our society? I'm eager to hear your reply, BobbyJohn. Thanks for beginning the conversation on this specific topic.
Mary Degon
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 4:33 p.m.
I have dedicated my life to animals, even became political when I realized the government thought they had the Right to tell me if I could legally own my dog! I was never much into politics before but now I actively campaign for dog ordinances that do not target any breed. I would never have imagined that I would be out there publicly speaking, but my Dogs deserve nothing less! My dogs are loyal, loving and dedicated to me, they are my family and they are mine. I would never allow anyone to persuade me to not rescue a dog in need -especially what people call Pit Bulls! I have 5 currently, and have fostered, adopted and helped in transport of hundreds more. I have had dogs from some of the worst places one could imagine, some of the most abused dogs that I thought no one would be able to 'reach'. They are all in loving homes now. Each negative remark or look only encourages me to ask if they would like to meet a real Pit Bull, if they would like to pet one and maybe talk about their perspective rather than rush on by in a huff or slam doors shut in fear of my dogs big lolling tongue and grunty hello's. As a comment below said, if you have never experience the pit bull - you just wont get it.
Lorrie Shaw
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 8:46 p.m.
Good for you for fighting the good fight. What do you think the best way to address the problem of so many dogs fitting the physical description of what we know now to be pit bull lodged in crime-ridden areas - and not being cared for, and/or used as a way to protect an area would be? Do you feel that any legislation that would be enacted would be enforcable?
kay
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 12:50 p.m.
I think maybe you have to be around a pit bull before you can really "get it." Now that I have one I fully see their intelligence, devotion, sweetness----how sad that some of the haters have to malign these dogs for their own benefit. And how ridiculous that I have to move to another city to keep my wonderful dog. Ann Arbor is considered "dog friendly", but try and find an apartment here that will let me keep my pit bull. Simply absurd!!!!!
Lorrie Shaw
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 8:38 p.m.
That's interesting, Kay. It is sad that humans have used dogs in a way that gas created fear. How do you feel about mandatory sterilization?
Chef Edelstein M
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 2:26 a.m.
Unfortunately... our society is MORE apt to sucome to peer pressure as individual thought and decision has become almost a crime. As for the "bully" breeds (a stupid nick name/ label, mind you)... we have 4. They are all rescues. We get snarls from neighbors and passers by all the time. This scenario provokes the most wonderful opportunity to educate and enlighten those who know everything they know about pit bulls from the media... which aint much except lies and ultra sensationalism. This breed, like ALL dog breeds, requires responsible ownership. Gang Bangers, Drug Dealers, Thugs and White Trash have no business owning this breed or ANY ANIMAL for that matter. These dogs are living/walking/thinking/intelligent beings and require care and structure and a pack to belong to... not electricution or over breeding or being fought or trained to be used for intimidation. Pit Bulls eat, sleep on the couch, poop, pee, run and play just like every other breed when they are responsibly owned and cared for. For the human element who would be persuaded by their peers to not own one of these dogs... you are better off not owning one and certainly dont possess the type of integrity it takes to responsibly own a pit bull.
Lorrie Shaw
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 8:34 p.m.
All great points, Chef. Sounds like you've got quite the happy family!
RuralMom
Thu, Aug 11, 2011 : 4:05 p.m.
I currently have 3 bully dogs! The first was a private rescue from an abusive situation. Once we had him, submissive peeing was an issue briefly that was triggered by any loud voice! We now have 2 puppies in the household and he is the most PATIENT animal with these pit bull puppies. They love to rough house and pick on him, yet he never ever loses paitience and seems to enjoy the position of elder/leader/alpha male dog. I would never allow someone to dissuade me from a dog based purely on the breed! Pit Bulls are the most intelligent breed of dog I have ever encountered!
Lorrie Shaw
Fri, Aug 12, 2011 : 8:33 p.m.
How exciting for your family, RuralMom! Glad that all of your family members are happy and are enjoying each others company.