You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Fri, Jul 26, 2013 : 12:51 p.m.

Ypsilanti schools authorizes restructuring $18.8M debt to no longer be a deficit district

By Danielle Arndt

070113_YPSI_COMM_SCHOOLS_BOARD2.JPG

The Ypsilanti Community Schools Board of Education and Superintendent Scott Menzel, far right, at the district's first official meeting on Monday, July 1, 2013. At Thursday's special meeting, the board approved an agreement that will allow the district to pay back its debt over 13 years.

Amy Biolchini | AnnArbor.com file photo

Previous coverage:

Beginning with its 2014 financial audit, Ypsilanti Community Schools' books will no longer show an operating deficit.

The Ypsilanti Board of Education Thursday authorized school officials to consolidate and refinance the unified district's $18.8 million debt and to proceed with an agreement with the Michigan Finance Authority to pay back that debt over a 13-year period.

The Michigan Finance Authority met Thursday morning in Lansing to approve the agreement and repayment period from its end. The district called a special board meeting for Thursday evening to set the wheels in motion on its side as well.

The new unified district inherited $18.8 million in debt from the former Willow Run Community Schools and Ypsilanti Public Schools. About $11.2 million of that total is the combined operating deficits from Ypsilanti and Willow Run, which began operating in the red during the 2009-10 and 2005-06 academic years, respectively.

The other approximately $7.6 million in debt YCS has an obligation to pay back is owed to the Michigan Finance Authority for money each district borrowed in 2012 to address cash flow issues and make payroll at certain low points in the year.

Because of the way Michigan disburses its per-pupil foundation allowance payments and because many districts no longer have fund equities or reserves to float money from to cover bills and pay staff in between aid payments, many districts have to borrow money from the state finance authority at the beginning of the year to ensure teachers and administrators won't go without pay during periods of low cash flow.

YCS Superintendent Scott Menzel said there are 240 Michigan districts that participate in the MFA's state aid note borrowing program.

Menzel originally had hoped for 15 years to pay back the $18.8 million debt. However, the Michigan Department of Treasury and the Finance Authority had their sights set on 10 years. So the 13-year repayment period was a compromise.

The MFA is issuing bonds rather than notes to pay off Ypsilanti's maturing debt and to raise the cash upfront that's needed to run the district. The difference between selling notes and selling bonds are the terms of maturity, YCS' legal counsel explained Thursday. Bonds generally are long-term investments.

The interest rate on the debt will be fixed once the bonds are sold. YCS officials are expecting an interest rate in the range of 3 to 6 percent.

YCS will pay off the debt in the amounts of $1 million the first year, $1.5 million the second year and $2 million in years three through 13, Menzel said.

The money for paying off the debt will be taken off the top of the district's state aid payments and will go directly to the treasury department.

Per the MFA agreement, the money for the loan will come from the district's state aid payments for January through July of each school year. There are seven state aid payments during that period.

Despite having the $18.8 million in outstanding debt, this agreement will make it look like the new unified district is operating in the black and will remove YCS from Michigan's growing list of school district's operating with a budget deficit.

Brian Marcel, the assistant superintendent of finances and operations for the Washtenaw Intermediate School District, who has been assisting YCS with this arrangement, essentially said the agreement turns the $18.8 million — from the state's standpoint — into more of an outstanding bond, rather than an outstanding debt.

The $18.8 million will be recorded in the district's budget as a revenue source and immediately will give YCS a $7.6 million positive fund balance.

"You are only guaranteed that for the one year," Marcel said to the board. "The financial decisions the district makes beyond the one year impacts whether that $7 million goes up or down."

The YCS Board of Education asked many questions Thursday night about the MFA agreement and about the future financial stability of the district. A few trustees expressed concerns about the money to pay back the debt being taken off the top of the district's per-pupil foundation allowance seven months of the year.

President David Bates stressed how the board and the district must work together to be intentional about attracting new families to YCS and increasing student enrollment.

Both Ypsilanti and Willow Run struggled in the past eight years with losing students to charter schools and nearby districts. Data reports compiled by school officials show that, together, the districts lost nearly 2,400 children in that time period.

For the 2013-14 academic year, YCS will receive $7,563 per pupil from the state. Taking $1 million from the district's per-pupil foundation allowance to pay down the debt essentially is the equivalent of 132 students more the district will have to attract to maintain its budget, Menzel said.

Danielle Arndt covers K-12 education for AnnArbor.com. Follow her on Twitter @DanielleArndt or email her at daniellearndt@annarbor.com.

Comments

YpsiTeacher

Sat, Jul 27, 2013 : 1:51 p.m.

Having an articulately crafted 7.5 million dollar fund equity is like saying that I have an $8,000 asset increase when I collect an $8,000 check from my auto insurance company designated to be paid to my auto body shop. Were I to spend that money on anything other than paying my bills, I would be left with an unpaid debt. I hope, in this politically framed language, the Board and administrators do not find a way to exceed their structural budget under the justification of any available fund balance. Borrowing against money borrowed to repay will simply push the debt to the same unmanageable level produced by the last YPS superintendent. Second, I find it terribly ironic that the current Board and ISD now need the community to make their great plans happen in the version of enrollment. I wonder how they justify their overt rejection of community voice, interest, or legitimacy as a strategy to produce community participation in the form of enrollment. Failing to attend to revenue streams shows novice business savvy.

YpsiGirl4Ever

Sun, Jul 28, 2013 : 6:53 a.m.

Excellent analysis Ypsi Teacher. We'll see what the future (both immediate and long-term) holds for YCS.

CountyKate

Fri, Jul 26, 2013 : 9:50 p.m.

As I already know of children whose parents are placing them in charter schools due to the horrendously managed rehiring of teachers and administrators, I wish the board luck in coming up with 132 extra students above the projections. But I don't place much faith in them reaching that goal.

jns131

Sat, Jul 27, 2013 : 2:41 p.m.

This is not due to the horrendous mismanagement of hiring but due to the fact that by combining WR and Ypsi children together is going to strain the resources of combining children that have long been rivals between the two and now they have to learn to get along and be a team. This is going to be one long year. Glad mine is not involved in it.

ahi

Fri, Jul 26, 2013 : 7:42 p.m.

"into more of an outstanding bond, rather than an outstanding debt" This doesn't mean anything. A bond is a type of debt for the issuing party. Unless I am very confused.

Zytiga

Fri, Jul 26, 2013 : 7:22 p.m.

Overall, the MFA agreement is a smart financial move. "For the 2013-14 academic year, YCS will receive $7,563 per pupil from the state. Taking $1 million from the district's per-pupil foundation allowance to pay down the debt essentially is the equivalent of 132 students more the district will have to attract to maintain its budget, Menzel said." I hope the current budget is not based on an increase of 132 students, or any increase. It is more likely the exodus of students will continue at the previous rate or even at a higher rate. Given this and the fact that under the current state leadership it is likely that annual increases in per pupil funding will not even keep pace with inflation, the district will have to be very frugal in its expenditures. Recent hirings do not suggest this will be the case, however.

beardown

Sun, Jul 28, 2013 : 12:25 p.m.

I think that they are doing just that. Nothing like putting yourself behind the eight ball before you even start. In a district that will struggle, at least at the start, to retain students, they are banking their financial future on bringing in more students. If the Ann Arbor school district has been having a problem increasing its enrollment (down 2 last year), how in their right minds does the YCS believe it will increase theirs? Especially by that many students?