Ypsilanti-Willow Run merger planning retreat focusing on district's design
The direction for a possible new school district in eastern Washtenaw County will be set Wednesday and Thursday this week, and public input could not be more crucial, said Washtenaw Intermediate School District Superintendent Scott Menzel.
The district that could emerge from Ypsilanti and Willow Run schools consolidation could be groundbreaking and bring economic prosperity to the east side of the county, Menzel said.
The retreat’s focus will be the strategic design of the new district.
Menzel said the two days are structured in such a way that it’s important for people to commit to attending both days for the full amount of time.
“We know it’s hard for people to take from morning to afternoon off to do this, but if they have the time and ability, we really want a broad cross section of the community,” he said.
The WISD can accommodate up to 100 people for the two-day retreat. Lunch will be provided both days, which is why officials are asking for an RSVP. Coffee and water also will be available in the mornings.
“The question we have to be answering is: Can (Ypsilanti and Willow Run) continue to exist as independent entities, given their current realities? And I don’t believe that they can,” Menzel said.
“Both districts are in a death spiral — that’s really what it if — and I don’t see any way out but unification. If we don’t do this, if we miss this (opportunity) — the moral implications, not to mention its economic imperative — it would be detrimental to the region.”
Menzel emphasized Ypsilanti and Willow Run’s rock-bottom test scores.
A recent data report shows how scores on the Michigan Education Assessment Program (MEAP) exam have dropped rapidly in Willow Run throughout the past four years, from 28 percent of third-graders testing proficient in math in 2008-09 to 4 percent in 2011-12. Similarly, eighth-grade math proficiencies fell from 45 percent proficient in 2007-08 to 10 percent in 2011-12.
“These are supposed to be predictors of success,” Menzel said.
He admitted the test scores are bleak, but said there are research-based strategies out there for improving student achievement.
“And that’s why we brought in (the) Lead and Learn (Institute) for the (strategic design) retreat,” Menzel said. “They have national experience with turnaround school districts like us. We know we can change the academic trajectory, but not with the cuts that are required to balance the budgets each year with the way things are now.”
He said consolidation is a chance at creating a new school system — one that employs the strategies and the people that are best fit for the community of Ypsilanti, its students and its unique challenges and strengths.
“People think schools always look a certain way, but it doesn’t have to look that way,” Menzel said. He cited Ypsilanti’s New Tech at Ardis, Washtenaw International High School and W-A-Y (Widening Advancements for Youth) as examples, adding New Tech has a long list of students waiting to get in.
He said one of the most frequently asked questions about the consolidation is what will happen to the districts’ buildings.
“There is an approach to learning that is not building dependent.”
He said this is a chance for school officials to do “creative things,” and that structure-based curriculum delivery is the most expensive way.
“We have to target what parents want, the types of educational opportunities that will lead to improvements in achievement and the supports that kids need — before we decide which assets we are going to use,” Menzel said. “We have a unique opportunity to really reinvent how the educational experience is delivered in eastern Washtenaw County.”
Wednesday and Thursday’s retreat will focus on developing the strategic direction of education at the possible new district.
Menzel said Washtenaw County has six colleges and universities within its boundaries. The Willow Run airport is an asset to the community and the soon-to-be second international trade crossing between Windsor, Ontario, and Detroit will bring many benefits to the area as well, he said.
Menzel said quality schools are a key part of a “larger vision” for revitalizing the region. The Ann Arbor/Ypsilanti (A2Y) Regional Chamber, the Eastern Leaders Group and SPARK East are all in support of the consolidation effort, he said.
“They know attracting new business and having good schools are hand in glove,” Menzel said.
Andy LaBarre, vice president of government affairs and administration for A2Y Chamber, said, from the chamber’s perspective, it is important the schools on the east side of the county have “every chance at success.”
“We think with this merger, it will allow (officials) to bring the strengths of each district together, and the end result will be a population of students who have the needed and necessary skills to be part of our workforce, whether it be immediately for those students who have jobs during high school, in the short term just out of high school or in the long term after college,” LaBarre said.
To RSVP for the two-day strategic design retreat, contact Emma Jackson, public relations director for the WISD, at ejackson@wash.k12.mi.us or (734) 994-8100, ext. 1321.
Comments
15crown00
Thu, Jul 19, 2012 : 5:07 p.m.
two losers getting together.WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!
boo
Wed, Jul 18, 2012 : 3:24 a.m.
agree with snoopdog. this is a disgrace. both of those school district should be closed. allow those families to use vouchers to choose any school district they wish to attend. Willow Run is dead, and it will get Ypsilanti, which is hanging by a thread, killed in the process. When or if this merger happens, you will see families leaving in droves. this will never work. and it shouldn't work.
jns131
Thu, Jul 19, 2012 : 3:25 a.m.
There is no school that will take them. Ann Arbor would love it but it will bring that district down to this districts level and then Ann Arbor would become another Belleville. A problem city with a problem school district when it opened up to school choice. Good luck with that one.
snoopdog
Wed, Jul 18, 2012 : 12:31 a.m.
You have two of the worst school districts in the state and you note they are both in a "death spiral". Yet you think combining them and targeting teaching techniques to "what the parents want" is going to make this work ? Come on Mr. Menzel, we all know this will never work, it might buy them a few more years but it will never work. 4% of third graders are proficient in math , what a disgrace ? Who is being held accountable for those miserable scores (heads should roll down the hallways) and what does proficient mean ? Is proficient a 70 out of 100 score ? Lot's of questions but no one has answers. Good Day
jns131
Thu, Jul 19, 2012 : 3:23 a.m.
They are not two of the worst, I can name a few in Detroit. But yes, I do agree, combining two schools is like putting out a fire with gasoline. Although, I am willing to give it a try and see what happens. You won't see my child or the next generation there. At least an EM can figure out the where with alls and hope there is no doom in it. Who knows, maybe there might be hope for this district after all?
sc8
Tue, Jul 17, 2012 : 11:39 p.m.
This has fail written all over it....and charter schools smell blood in the water.
jns131
Thu, Jul 19, 2012 : 11:13 p.m.
I can't say who told me, but I am hearing the Leona Group is taking over a school district. Can't wait to find out where.
pseudo
Tue, Jul 17, 2012 : 7:26 p.m.
I fail to follow the logic leap that unification is a solution to the" death spirals". Combining two failing districts just doesn't make sense for the students. And scare tactics like "death spiral" feel like more of a sales push than a conversation about student achievement.
xmo
Tue, Jul 17, 2012 : 5:22 p.m.
What will happen to all of those jobs that are duplicated in both districts? You cannot eliminate them so I guess the students will just get less money while the payroll remains the same!
jns131
Thu, Jul 19, 2012 : 3:21 a.m.
Actually not. They are closing the WR High School. They are going to need teachers there to teach. Although I hate to say it, there are some who should not be teaching. It will be up to MEA to discuss who gets the ax and who does not. Good luck with that one. Can't wait to see the pendulum swing.
sc8
Tue, Jul 17, 2012 : 6:15 p.m.
The duplicate jobs get cut of course!