New Ann Arbor fire chief has task of figuring out how to maintain services with fewer firefighters
After more than 25 years with the Ann Arbor Fire Department, Chuck Hubbard is now the city's new fire chief after being promoted to the position Monday night.
The Ann Arbor City Council voted unanimously to make Hubbard, one of two assistant chiefs in the department, head of the city's fire services.
Hubbard will report to Police Chief Barnett Jones, the city's safety services administrator, who served as interim fire chief after Dominick Lanza resigned from the post in March.
Ryan J. Stanton | AnnArbor.com
Jones said Hubbard understands Ann Arbor and has extensive experience as a firefighter, driver-operator, lieutenant, battalion chief and assistant chief. He said Hubbard "wants to be a part of doing something different because the times are different."
"I guess I'm standing here proud to say that the city administrator is backing me and my ability to recognize that Chuck has all the talents that we need," Jones told council members.
Jones said it's notable that the city was able to promote someone to fire chief from within the department. It's the first time that's happened for at least two decades, he said.
The city has struggled to keep the fire chief position filled in recent years. Counting nine chiefs Ann Arbor has employed in the last decade, the firefighters union believes the department has suffered from a lack of consistent leadership.
The union could not be reached for comment Monday night.
The last two fire chiefs to resign both cited strong pressure from the city's administration to make cuts as a reason for leaving, and both left citing concerns about the staffing levels.
Hubbard told council members he's looking forward to working with them to bridge the gap between the fire department and the city's leadership. Relations between the two sides have been poor in recent years with the fire department's budget continually under attack.
"We do have some good people across the street who really want to do a good job and they really care, and I'm going to bring that out and show you that," Hubbard said.
Hubbard's new salary was not immediately available. According to the council resolution approving his promotion, he holds a business management degree from Eastern Michigan University.
The fire department will see its ranks decrease from 89 to 82 full-time career firefighters July 1 after the latest round of budget cuts.
That leaves the city with 0.72 firefighters per 1,000 residents. According to the National Fire Protection Association, the average full-time career fire department in the United States has about 1.72 firefighters per 1,000 residents.
Hubbard said he's awaiting the results of an ongoing study of fire department staffing levels by the International City/County Management Association. Once that report is back, he said he'll be sitting down with the department's senior officers to discuss the department's next steps.
The city began a new practice in mid-February of closing one of the city's five fire stations on a rotating basis to curtail overtime costs as needed. Each month a different station is assigned to be closed and property owners receive service from the nearest open fire station.
Hubbard acknowledged in an interview with AnnArbor.com he's considering an alternative plan to shut down one of the downtown fire trucks as needed — instead of continuing rolling station closures, which the union claims has increased response times.
"What we're going to try to do is better manage and deploy our units," Hubbard said. "Each one of our substations has one truck. Downtown has two plus a battalion chief. And when you've got two trucks in one station and everybody else has one, it's kind of a no-brainer to think, 'Why are we closing a station when we can just take one of these trucks out?'"
Hubbard said taking one of the downtown fire trucks out of service wouldn't be a permanent move — it would only happen if daily staffing levels fall below 19 firefighters.
He said the department tries to staff 25 firefighters on any given shift. In order to keep all six trucks up and running, it needs 19 firefighters on duty.
"So as long we have less than seven people off, we're good," he said. "But once we get below that 19, then we come up short and we have to figure out what's going to be the best and the safest way to do things."
The two downtown trucks are Rescue One and Tower One. Hubbard said the truck that might be taken out of service as needed is Tower One, one of two ladder trucks in the city.
The other ladder truck is stationed at North Campus.
"Keep in mind, the truck is more of a defensive-type vehicle and we have very few defensive-type fires," Hubbard said.
The firefighters union has raised concerns that taking the downtown ladder truck out of service could be dangerous.
Hubbard agreed it's not an ideal situation.
"No matter where you close something, you could have bad news — there's just no good answer to it. It's just a no-win situation," he said. "We have to be careful how we do that. Nobody wants to close any stations or any trucks, but if we get to the situation where we have to, it's not a permanent thing — it's just on a need-be basis."
Ryan J. Stanton covers government and politics for AnnArbor.com. Reach him at ryanstanton@annarbor.com or 734-623-2529. You also can follow him on Twitter or subscribe to AnnArbor.com's e-mail newsletters.
Comments
Stephen Lange Ranzini
Wed, Jun 8, 2011 : 12:38 p.m.
Taking Tower One, the only fire truck in the city able to reach upper floors of tall buildings, out of service puts all residents of high rise buildings at risk any day that this occurs. City Council is rolling the dice with our lives despite having the money in the rainy day fund to avoid this! Even contemplating building more tall buildings downtown (see this morning's news) is irresponsible and will require MORE fire fighting resources, not less. I support greater downtown density but you've got to provide the safety resources - police and fire protection - this requires!
areyoukiddingme
Wed, Jun 8, 2011 : 4:10 p.m.
Maybe there should be a clarification of "taking it out of service". Does that mean "never to be used, or, parked at the downtown station till it's needed"? The article did say there is 1 other Tower Truck in service so, it's not as if we'd be left with no Tower Truck. IF there is ever a High-Rise fire, A2 will need more than Fire fighters on that day which means calling in support staff. At that time, the Tower Truck can be deployed. Which would you rather have, this big truck driving around when a much smaller vehicle could be used or, having it in the middle of the city ready to go when needed? Streets in A2 are crowded enough as it is, why use it unless you have to?
Carole
Wed, Jun 8, 2011 : 11:56 a.m.
Congratulations to Mr. Hubbard and wishing you the very best for indeed, AAFD are the very best. It is wonderful that someone within the department has been hired for the chief's position. Will continue to lobby for not reducing the department employees and support AAFD as well as AAPD.
Mr. Tibbs
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 5:52 p.m.
why doesn't the city council try to tackle the huge wages garnered by the 3rd floor to help pay for more people on the other end of the shovel/firehose/badge/whatever?
Townie
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 4:29 p.m.
Congrats and condolences to Mr. Hubbard. While it's nice they're finally promoting from within I'm wondering if Mr. Hubbard with 25 years in is stuck with 'not rocking the boat' for 5 years to reach the '30 and out' stage (I don't know how it works in A2). Who would risk the axe that close to pension time if that's the case? It wouldn't surprise me that the powers that be in Ann Arbor City gov't made the decision that this poor guy wouldn't upset their little apple cart until they run out the clock and quietly sneak away from the mess they have created.
hmmmm
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 5:19 p.m.
@Townie - I believe its 25 years and out. It seems to me that Chief Hubbard's intentions and ability to run this department are being decided based on the city's previous Chiefs. I think based on his time in THIS department he has more of a vested interest in working with the city to create a better image of the fire department along with improving relations between the fire department, council and the citizens of AA. Let's just give him a fair chance before making assumptions that he "is stuck with not rocking the boat for 5 years".
Craig Lounsbury
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 2:18 p.m.
"Counting nine chiefs Ann Arbor has employed in the last decade, ...." If memory serves me some of those "chiefs" were interim's who rolled through the office just long enough to max out their pensions under the contract rules at the time. They only intended to sit in the seat just long enough, then pass it on to the next guy in line. This occurred during a time when "we" were in one of those infamous national searches for the "perfect fit". That is kind of how I remember it.
Craig Lounsbury
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 3:08 p.m.
"Are you implying this is Chief Hubbard's intentions?" NO NO NO. Further more nothing I wrote even remotely suggests that. I am taken aback that you could draw any conclusion like that from my words.
areyoukiddingme
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 2:35 p.m.
Are you implying this is Chief Hubbard's intentions? If so, I must have missed something in the article or you know something the rest of us don't. I don't see where it says "interim Chief Hubbard". Might be a litle early to be making assumptions.. IMO -the fact he's been in the Department as long as he has means he's more interested in sticking around than previous Chiefs.
Ricebrnr
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 1:28 p.m.
Congratulations, this is the first time in quite a while, that they promoted from within, no? Nice to have someone step into the job who has a history and understands the needs of the department. Hopefully he will have the fortitude to fight City Hall...
Kai Petainen
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 12:48 p.m.
Chief Hubbard... 25 years at the AAFD. thank you for your service/work... congrats on the new position and best wishes. ""I'm smiling because this is a welcome event to take place," said Jones, who has been lobbying for a new full-time fire chief" And Jones... thank you, to you as well.
steve h
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 6:14 p.m.
and thank you for not mentioning the Huron River spill
areyoukiddingme
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 12:32 p.m.
I'd like to be one of the first to congratulate Chief Hubbard on his new position. Having been with the Ann Arbor Fire Dept. for 25 years I'm sure he realizes the challenges he will have. Based upon his remarks it sounds like he has a good grasp on what the issues are and is willing to do needs to be done.
Mi resident
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 11:52 a.m.
Why doesn't the city of Ann Arbor try proposing a public millage in order to keep Fire Fighters and the stations fully staffed? Pittsfield area residents welcomed the increase in order to keep the township safe.
Ricebrnr
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 1:26 p.m.
Because as AA and history has shown us, for all their "buckets" the administration can't be trusted to use all of that money where it was intended. They will simply raise fees for ancillary services to the department to siphon that money off. And it would interfere with their apparent plans to completely dismantle safety services in this town.
DDOT1962
Tue, Jun 7, 2011 : 10:56 a.m.
Good luck to Mr. Hubbard, in a role that seems to have very little upside. He'll face continuing pressure from Jones and council to shrink his department's budget and at the same time he'll be forced to cull positions among the rank and file from which he came. Not my idea of fun. Then again, he's also got his 25 years in, and now he's at the highest promotional level possible, so his retirement will be nicely afforded. If push comes to shove, I'm sure the city could be looking at the position being vacant again in a couple of years...