Washtenaw County Board has tough decisions to make; 181 county jobs on the line
Washtenaw County administrator Bob Guenzel has laid out options for trimming an additional $11.7 million from the county budget.
That includes the potential elimination of 181 full-time jobs in county government, Guenzel regretfully told commissioners at Wednesday's County Board meeting. But facing a potential $30 million structural deficit over the 2010-11 budget cycle, the county has little choice but to make deep cuts, Guenzel said.
“These aren't options we bring to you lightly,” he said. “These are valuable programs but we're running out of options.”
County leaders first identified a $26 million structural deficit for the 2010-11 biennial budget cycle back in February. Last month, commissioners voted on $12.8 million in cuts for 2010 and an additional $800,000 for 2011.
Wednesday's meeting marked the beginning of Phase II of budget reduction talks. County officials now are taking a hard look at unmandated services the county funds.
Guenzel said his budget priorities are to preserve as many services and jobs as possible, but that will take concessions from labor unions.
“Counties are the most important government in Michigan because all we do is provide services to people,” Guenzel said. “And we can't provide those services without people that are here in jobs and positions, so that's been really at the top of our list.”
Wednesday's meeting drew a standing-room-only crowd of more than 100 people who spilled out of the board room, lined the hallways and filled chairs in the lobby. For more than an hour, commissioners listened to heartfelt pleas from the residents, community leaders and county employees who showed up to ask that the county find ways to maintain funding for the various programs now on the chopping block.
One budget option before commissioners involves eliminating county support for the Michigan State Unniversity Extension, which could save $424,220. But it also would hurt 4-H programs that develop life skills in Washtenaw County youths.
Cindy Strader, a 4-H club leader, appeared before commissioners with Marta Swenson and Riley Kent, two members from her club.
“I can't imagine this wonderful organization being cut, serving as many youth as it does in such positive ways,” Strader said. “We are asking that the commissioners look harder, get even more creative and find a way to continue this funding.”
No final decisions were made Wednesday. Guenzel said he'll be coming back to commissioners on Sept. 16 with final recommendations.
“We do hear you,” Commissioner Kristin Judge, D-7th District, assured Wednesday's speakers. “We are taking this very seriously and we understand the importance of all these programs,” she added, encouraging those who spoke to help the county come up with ways to keep programs alive.
“These are all great programs. If they weren't great programs, we wouldn't be doing them,” said Commissioner Jeff Irwin, D-11th District, who indicated he's not looking forward to the tough decisions the board must make.
Guenzel said the county continues to monitor and revise its budget assumptions. A revised forecast shows county revenues are projected to total $91.4 million in 2011, while expenditures reach $121.6 million - a $30 million shortfall unless cuts are made.
Officials also predict taxable values will continue to slide in the next two years - by 7.5 percent in 2010 and by 8.5 percent in 2011.
Commissioners Wednesday discussed implementing a Public Act 88 millage to fund economic development efforts in the county. A levy of 0.017 mills could be added to the tax rolls without voter approval to support the county's contribution to SPARK, which promotes economic development, and other eligible services, officials said. The tax could save the county $256,000, while costing homeowners $1.70 per $100,000 of taxable value. Public Act 88 allows counties to levy a millage of up to 5 cents per $100 of taxable value to promote economic activity.
Several unmandated services face potential elimination. Guenzel said the county could save $239,547 through the elimination of building inspection services, an unmandated program with little market demand at this time.
The county could realize up to $2.4 million in savings through reductions to mental health services, which would eliminate 91.4 full-time jobs. Another $586,000 in reductions are on the table for public and environmental health, and up to $1.1 million in cuts are being considered in strategic planning, including elimination of the the Planning Advisory Board and Planning Commission.
The support services department faces $750,000 in cuts, affecting six full-time employees.
Head Start is another unmandated program on the chopping block, which could free up $765,880 in the budget. About 35 full-time county employees would be affected.
County officials indicated Wednesday they may also consider eliminating the county's juvenile detention program and sending youth to other facilities to save $919,464. Doing so would eliminate about 24 full-time positions.
Guenzel said $1.7 million could be saved by eliminating human services funding, though some worry whether agencies that receive funding from the county would survive further reductions. Other options on the table include $205,586 in reductions in professional development and $1.9 million in cuts to retiree health care, which would affect more than 700 county retirees.
County officials also are considering saving $460,000 by eliminating funding of special initiatives, such as Eastern County Economic Development, the Supportive Housing Initiative and the Housing Contingency Fund, which supports foreclosure programs.
“There's a lot more work to do,” Guenzel said. “There may be other options but these are the ones we've been looking at pretty seriously.”
The board has a working session scheduled for 6:30 tonight at the County Administration Building, 220 N. Main St., to discuss a county health improvement plan, food safety regulation and next steps for a county land bank authority.
Photos by Ryan Stanton, AnnArbor.com: Top: Washtenaw County commissioners listen to pleas to save programs at Wednesday's meeting. Bottom: Youths from 4-H address the board about their desire to see support continue for 4-H.
Ryan Stanton covers government for AnnArbor.com. He can be reached at 734-623-2529 or ryanstanton@annarbor.com.
Comments
sageaa
Fri, Aug 7, 2009 : 3:18 p.m.
While salinesal makes some good points, "promoting the General welfare" includes protecting the most vulnerable in our community. Otherwise we have a survival of the fittest society...which is fine if you are in that group and not unlucky enough to be born with disabilities,mental and/or physical. Our better selves strive for a more perfect union where all have a chance to pursue happiness. I believe the Board must protect these citizens and expect nothing less.
salinesal
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 5:15 p.m.
These decisions are not that hard to make when you take your guidance from the U.S. and Michigan Constitutions. The question goes to...what is the purpose of Government? The Preamble states that the purpose of Government is to..."establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity" The "General Welfare" clause goes to only those specific enumerated items as defined in the Constitution and only as they affect ALL the People as individuals. Not any special interest, not the 4H, or any other group. As good as their programs may be, and as good as those spending money on those programs may make politicians feel...they are not in the confines of the "limited Government" that our Forefathers created. So in summery.. the purpose of Government is to protect our lives, protect our liberty, protect our property and establish a system of justice to resolve any disputes we may have. If you can do those things, "We the People" can fill in for all the rest.
a2huron
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 12:51 p.m.
I would bet that we could see a vastly different county board next time around as voters will look for representatives that actively represent their constituents and not outside interests or other regions of the county. It begins and ends with accountability.
slyde734
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 12:29 p.m.
The sad truth is the Commissioners response has been so pathetic and tepid, that the cuts will be far more harsh than they needed to be. Most of them have been dutifully protecting their own pet projects while ignoring the impending budget meet. Most of the other Counties in the region recognized the depth of problem many months ago, and have taken action to address the situation. Unfortunatly, the Washtenaw County Board has sat on their hands and waited thinking that things would just get better. The board is devoid of quality leadership and they should be ashamed.
treetowncartel
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 11:56 a.m.
Maybe they could tax local breweries more?
glimmertwin
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 10:44 a.m.
Maybe the county should build a new jail. That will really save alot.
uawisok
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 10:34 a.m.
I'm suprised they don't take the low road like most private sector companies and go get a bunch of H1B1 Visa emplyees who will work for 1/2 the wages of American citizens who are looking for work....oh by the way editors this is a rhetorical statement that has value added and is low calorie and high in fiber...LOL
BigApple
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 9:59 a.m.
This situation is really ugly for washtenaw county. The county is at point where they are becoming unable to provide necessary programs for the troubled youth and it makes no sense at all. I believe that the construction sites and other meaningless endeavors to open up and free money for the things that really matter.
a2huron
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 9:30 a.m.
And how much of my Ann Arbor tax dollars used by the county continue to go towards subsidizing road patrols for Ypsilanti Twp and for paying ongoing legal costs for that lawsuit? Probably to the tune of a few dozen county employees or county services that will otherwise be cut. Nice.
Mumbambu, Esq.
Thu, Aug 6, 2009 : 7:48 a.m.
What a sucky situation. I sympathize with the Commissioners. Did I really just say that? Wow!