Hundreds rally for immigration rights outside University of Michigan commencement
Mark Bialek for AnnArbor.com
From one end of the political spectrum to the other, protesters turned out Saturday to send a message to President Barack Obama and to play to a crowd that numbered more than 80,000.
By far, the largest group was made up of supporters of immigration rights. A few hundred members of several local groups concerned about immigration issues rallied at Frisinger Park about a mile from the stadium and later marched there after the commencement ceremony began.
“This isn’t a rally against the president, this is a rally to remind him,” Ann Arbor resident Dave DeVarti said. “He made a commitment to us, I’m here to remind him of that commitment.”
DeVarti said he gave up his own ticket to hear Obama in order to attend the rally at the park.
Mark Bialek for AnnArbor.com
But in the end, protesters played a minor role in the day, far outnumbered by crowds of graduates and family members.
Before the ceremony began, a few groups of demonstrators concerned about various issues, including taxes and abortion, protested outside the stadium. Members of the Tea Party, who oppose the president's economic policies, had called for supporters to line South Main Street from Scio Church Road to the Pauline Boulevard. But fewer than 20 were gathered outside the stadium. By the time the graduation crowd made its way through the gates and past security at the football stadium, a few dozen protesters stood outside in relative quiet.
At the park, rally participants carried American flags and signs with sayings like “Stop Ripping Families Apart,” “Arizona’s Not the Standard,” and “Obama Don’t Deport My Momma.” The demonstrators rallied against Arizona’s recent crackdown on illegal immigrants and for the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act. The legislation would allow undocumented high school students who have been in the United States for more than five years the chance to earn conditional permanent residency and eventually a path to citizenship after a six-year probationary period.
“We want Obama to know to stop the separation of families,” Belleville resident Alberto Torres said.
Just a few weeks ago, a friend of his was arrested in front of his 5-year-old son before being deported back to Mexico, Torres said.
Ypsilanti resident Cassandra Moreno said she also attended the rally to fight to keep her own family together.
Angele Cesere | AnnArbor.com
Moreno, seven months pregnant, is expecting her fourth child with her husband who is an illegal immigrant.
“We kind of need something to happen so we can keep our family together,” she said. “There’s no way for him to find a way to become legal.”
Concern about keeping families together is what prompted Laura Saunders to co-found the Washtenaw Interfaith Coalition for Immigrant Rights two years ago. Saunders, one of several speakers at the rally, said a local crackdown on immigrants led to many children being separated from their parents and placed into foster care.
“It’s become a huge problem for everyone in our community,” she said.
Other speakers shared their own stories about growing up as an undocumented citizen.
An 18-year-old woman named Maribel, who wouldn't give her last name for fear of deportation, said she arrived in the U.S. at age 2 and did not even realize she was undocumented until years later when she could not obtain a library card.
She said it hurt her feelings to be denied rights in a country she loved. She said she had always been proud to recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
“I always stood tall, because this is my home,” she said. “This is everything to me.”
The rally finished with the march to the stadium where participants chanted outside as the ceremony got under way.
For Mohammed Abdollahi of Michigan One, the rally was an attempt to grab the president’s attention while he was here.
“We want to show Obama, regardless of his failed promises, we haven’t forgotten,” he said. “We’re not going to let him just walk away.”
Mark Bialek for AnnArbor.com
Before the ceremony, a dozen Tea Party members stood on the corner of Main Street and Stadium Boulevard holding signs. Another few walked around outside the stadium. Tim Anthony, of Westland, arrived about 7 a.m. carrying a "don't-tread-on-me" flag. He said weather had kept protesters' numbers low. Others said Tea Party supporters were attending a visit by Sarah Palin in Clarkston today. Anthony said he was there protesting the stimulus package, health care reform, cap and trade energy policies and immigration. "I'm here to protest President Obama's policies pure and simple. We're the silent majority,” he said.
Wes Nakagiri, a Tea Party supporter, came alone from from Hartland, and wore his old graduation cap and gown. He carried a sign carrying the golden arches of McDonald's and the title “Obamanomics, PhD.” Nakagiri said he was protesting Obama’s economic policies of rescuing banks and carmakers.
About 50 protesters with Citizens for a Pro-life Society based in South Lyon stood outside the stadium, some with poster-size signs meant to shock. They were hoping to have a group of more than 200 but rain kept some people away, said Monica Migliorino Miller, who was arrested for trespassing last year when Obama spoke at the Notre Dame University commencement. This time, the group was careful to stay off university property, she said. The protest, she said, was an opportunity to "show tens of thousands of people what abortion really is.”
Ed Mahony of Ann Arbor was a one-man protest as he walked up and down South Main Street and Stadium Boulevard carrying a sign calling for an end to the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. “I don't know why there aren't more protesters," he said. "There's a lot of apathy out there.” It’s still important to protest the wars, even though Obama did not start them, he said. “It doesn't matter who started it. It's got to stop."
Janet Miller contributed to this story.
Erica Hobbs is a reporter for AnnArbor.com. Reach her at 734-623-2537 or via e-mail at ericahobbs@annarbor.com.
Comments
Diagenes
Wed, May 5, 2010 : 7:03 a.m.
The federal legislature has ignored the problem of illegal immigration for many years. Democrats see unfettered immigration as a way to grow the welfare state, and their political power. Republicans see them as cheap labor, willing to do jobs Americans wont. The federal legislature, once agin for political reasons, has failed the American public, by refusing to secure our borders. It is well past time we replace all federal legislators with someone who will put the American people first and party second. BTW Federal law REQUIRES legal immigrants to carry proof of legal status at all times. If you have to carry it, its implied you can be asked to show it.
JSA
Mon, May 3, 2010 : 11:33 a.m.
I wonder how many of the protesters are actually citizens and how many are illegals?
outdoor6709
Sun, May 2, 2010 : 5:31 p.m.
The AA.com has the title wrong. It is not Immigration rights that were being protested for. It was privigles for illegal immigrants they are protesters are supporting. Someone name me one country in the world that has unregulated borders. Not Canada, not Mexico, definately not Cuba, China, or Iran. The current welfare state mentality in US makes it unsustainable to take money by force of government edict (taxes for those of you who want it simple) for one person to pay for the wants of another. I support immigrants that come to the US legally and add to our society. Because the US government has not taken the threat of illeagal immigration seriously, Phoenix has the 2nd highest kidnapping rate in the world. Who would have guessed?
Jay Allen
Sun, May 2, 2010 : 11:24 a.m.
I am sorry, but illegal means ILLEGAL and you have no rights. If you cannot take the required steps to remain here legally, then STOP with the grandstanding about changing laws. And I think it is funny that a blurb needs to be made in an attempt to change the focus of this thread. It is and was obvious the "tone" of this thread was about illegal immigration, why anything had to be said about "tea party" demonstrators is ludicrous.
GRANDPABOB
Sun, May 2, 2010 : 10:36 a.m.
OBAMA has always talked a good show! I can't understand how ILLEGAL immigrants can sneak in to this country and then demand the rights our forefathers fought and died for!Our politicians are worried about their jobs come fall and want to legalize these illegals to get their votes and they think the rest of us don't realise that.
InsideTheHall
Sun, May 2, 2010 : 5:49 a.m.
LD...Let me get this right. Employers can ask for papers but law enforcement cannot?????? Why burden the business owner, there should never be a question of who is legal or illegal if government does their job as they should.
tracyann
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 6:47 p.m.
According to Cassandra Moreno, "There's no way for him (her husband) to find a way to become legal". Really? How do other immigrants do it then? If someone wants to be here, great, but please go about it legally. By the way, undocumented = illegal.
LDIdeals
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 4:27 p.m.
What a fabulous commencement today; indeed, President Obama is a President to be proud of and apparently the crowd felt the same with the roaring cheers he received repetitively. Regarding immigration reform, I'm all for it but I say START WITH THE EMPLOYERS who hire illegals to save a buck and fine the heck out of them... they are the real ones that take jobs from Americans! Instead of scaring the heck out of anyone not looking like your average white guy in Arizona go right to the root with the ones trying to truck load cheap labor into the country.
Macabre Sunset
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 3:41 p.m.
I'm all for legal immigration. It's what made our country what it is today. I'm against people who cut in line. Why does immigration reform have to mean that people who cut in line are rewarded?
Edward R. Murrow's ghost
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 2:36 p.m.
How many tea partyers? Lotsa noise and smoke about them on discussion boards. Can we have an official report?
Commoncents
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 1:34 p.m.
If you're here illegally go home or take the steps to stay legally. It angers me to think of all the "free" services illegals get from hard working tax payers, let alone the crimes many of them commit.. By the way, I looked all over for the tea party at the graduation today and couldn't find them. Anyone that was there see them? Disappointing.
townie54
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 1:13 p.m.
Oh thats great come into another country illegally and then get the laws changed because you dont like them.Try that in any other country in the world.The U.S SHOULD STOP GIVING MONEY TO mEXICO until they clean up their corrupt government,police and Army.With all the resources Mexico has there is no reason why they cant develop the country and have jobs for everyone so people will stay there and work.I have voted Democrat all my life but I wont next time because I agree with republicans on health care and Immigration.
Snehal
Sat, May 1, 2010 : 12:48 p.m.
In what way people do not understand what ILLEGAL means? With all due respect for children who ar eborn here, it is not a justification to pardon their parents who BROKE law and came here. Many a times, children bear the fruits of their parents misgivings like a child of broken family. I do support the law and believe that illegal immigrants should be penalized. There is no justification to the fact that you can break into somebody's house and then claim rights. And nobody is forcing children to stay back. They can go back to their own country with their parents who were illegal here. So, where is the question of broken family here? Just because my household provides me crap is no reason to go to neighbors house to get good food. Why should we as LEGAL immigrants pay the price of millions of ILLEGAL people?