Making death notifications is one of the toughest jobs in police work
When driving to these calls, it's best not to think about your family. Before arriving, officers must be armed with as much information as possible. While walking to the front door, they must stay focused. On the front porch, it’s a good time take a few deep breaths, get determined and remember calm, compassion and common sense.
One of the toughest jobs in police work is making death notifications. Most death notifications are made in the hospital by social workers or doctors. However, when a death occurs at a catastrophe, accident or questionable death scene that the police are investigating, officers will make the death notification.
Death notifications by enlightened police departments are made in person. Normally, two officers will make a death notification and at least one of them will be in uniform, especially in hours of darkness. If time allows, sometimes a chaplain will accompany the officers, but that's usually not possible.
The manner in which officers impart the bad news can significantly impact the length of the mourning process for a family. Mothers Against Drunk Driving completed a study about how the police should properly handle death notifications, and these studies have been the basis for many police policies for death notifications.
Photo courtesy of the U.S. Air Force
If a death occurs in the city, Ann Arbor Police Department officers will make the notification if the family or next-of-kin live locally. If a death occurs in the city and next-of-kin live in another jurisdiction, the other police department will be asked to make the notification. That is where problems can occur.
Not all departments believe in making death notifications in person. One such agency I called to make a death notification merely called the dead man’s wife, gave her my phone number and told her to call because I had something to tell her. Getting tragic news is bad enough, but getting the run around to get the news was even worse. I felt terrible for this woman and anger at the other police department.
Reactions of loved ones who receive a death notification can run the gamut between quiet resolve to slapping an officer to fainting. I know of one case where a mother dropped dead when she heard her daughter had been murdered. For these reasons, there are normally two officers present when a death notification is made.
The officers involved will try to get the family inside and seated before making the notification. Seating the survivors is done to make them more comfortable and reduce injury in the case of an immediate shock response, such as fainting.
Another recommendation that MADD made was for the officers involved to use very concrete terms to describe the death. Officers must use terms like: killed, died and dead. Death messengers must avoid softening the impact by using terms like passed away, lost or expired.
The reason for using unambiguous and seemingly insensitive words is that the more ambiguous terms give the survivor false hope. The survivor does not want to believe his or her loved one is dead, and as a defense mechanism will hear only what gives them hope.
This happened at a homicide where a woman saw her husband lying in a pool of blood and fled to another apartment to call 911. After medical personnel arrived, they discovered the husband was dead. A well-meaning officer told the woman her husband had “passed away.” The woman looked relieved and said, “Thank God, what hospital did they take him to?” The officer had to explain a second time.
The MADD study also recommended that officers be honest and answer any questions the family may have, as long as it wouldn't compromise an investigation. This seemed counterintuitive because most officers felt they were “helping” by making the death sound either peaceful or instantaneous. Everyone grieves a little differently. Some family members want to know every detail, some only want the basics and some are just in shock and aren't really listening.
Officers will facilitate arrangements for other family members, neighbors or clergy to come help comfort the survivors. The officers involved will explain to the calmest survivor where the loved one’s remains will be located — usually the morgue. Sometimes, families will ask the officer to call a funeral home and give them the information about the location of their loved one.
The goal at a death notification is to impart the tragic information, keep the family safe, make sure they are cared for and give the family a point of contact for their inevitable questions. The questions will come after the initial shock, usually soon after burial. When the family picks up a person’s belongings, at the police department, it is a good time for the investigating officers to answer the family’s question.
These can be some tough conversations, but looking back on my career, they are some of the most rewarding. This is an opportunity for an officer to provide closure for a family by exchanging information. It can also establish a bond between the family and investigating officer if the case is a homicide.
Lock it up, don’t leave it unattended, be aware and watch out for your neighbors.
Rich Kinsey is a retired Ann Arbor police detective sergeant who now blogs about crime and safety for AnnArbor.com.
Comments
Michigan Reader
Fri, Jan 28, 2011 : 11:55 p.m.
I once had to tell a friend that an someone he knew had been murdered by serial killer Coral Eugene Watts. It may not sound so hard, until you try it yourself. It was the hardest thing I can remember telling anybody.
RJA
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 8:47 p.m.
Again Rich, I have to compliment you on your story. Police Officers wear many hats, and this must be one of the worst. (to notify family) Back in the early 70's , my husband was killed on a snowmobile. I heard it on the police scanner. Code K! They were going to visit his mother to notify her. I called Wayne County and said NO, she had just lost her husband, a month prior, she had tried to wake him in his recliner to go to bed) and he was dead, and now her son. Take his sisters with you. (he had just left his one sister's home) So I called her to let her know. Then it was my task to wake up my son and tell him (12 yrs.old) that his daddy died in a snowmobile accident. The Police were wonderful! They do go beyond the call of duty. I will forever say they don't get paid enough for what they do.
Sue Darnell
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 7:15 p.m.
Unfortunately when my son was killed in the UP by another snowmobiler who had been drinking the lone state trooper who came to notify me was very young and I almost wondered if that was his first face to face death notification. He pronounced my son's name incorrectly and gave me the name of a county in southern Michigan where the accident took place. Of course I said he must have gone to the wrong address because the info wasn't correct and my son was in the UP. After several more pieces of information he finally gave me the name of the friend who was with my son and then it was horribly real. After having some time to think about it, it must have been one the hardest things the officer ever had to do.
Matt Whale
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 6:06 p.m.
Thank you officers! I have never been through this and I don't know how it feels and hopefuly I won't. I'm sure it makes the officer feel bad to inform them their loved one has passed away.
jcj
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 5:07 p.m.
Thanks Rich. This was a very good article. I have gone through this notification and the officer was very helpful.
breadman
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 3:19 p.m.
Hello that is a very tough job to make a house call for a death. I lived on the other end of the state of few years back, to be looking out the window and a MSP car pulled in the driveway walked up to the house. Next ? was, how well we knew the lady across the street. Very well becaues she was only 28 1/2 yrs. old he was only31 1/2, too let us go with him to let her know her husband was killed. And by his ID knew it was a young family. Yes she had just had a set of twin girls 13 days before and lost there dad that they got to never know. Yes that is a very hard job!!!!! When you have a family that young..
Judith
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 3:03 p.m.
I think Rich is one of your best columnists. My husband and I had a visit from two Ann Arbor policemen at 2:00 a.m. exactly three years ago to inform us our daughter had died on the West Coast; the police there hadn't been able to reach us and notified our police to call on us as such notification must be done in person. On this, the worst moment of our lives, the officers were professional and kind; even in my grief, I was impressed with these young men, knew that this must be one of their worst duties, and wanted to try to make their job easier if possible. They gave us the phone number of the police in our daughter's city and - maybe this is part of their job too? - offered to stay longer with us if we needed them. This was a very interesting column. We're all fortunate to have such well-trained, compassionate policemen in Ann Arbor.
Pilgrim
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 2:29 p.m.
This article ranks as one of Rich's best. He writes it with such compassion. What a wonderful way to highlight the professionalism of the police department!! I would hope they get support from each other to deal with the stresses involved in providing these notifications. Thank you so much, Rich...
ThaKillaBee
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 1:30 p.m.
Thanks for sharing this. It's something I've always wondered about.
actionjackson
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : noon
I don't envy alot of what the police personell have to do out in the field. Death notification has to be right up there with the worst of the situations. Thanks to those that are out there and dealing with everything from combat to compassion.
KathrynHahn
Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 11:42 a.m.
It's good to ask them if they have a funeral home they want to use, an drecommend a local one if they don't. It's good to know all they have to do is tell the funeral home where the body is and everything will be taken care of from there. It's not a good time for loved one's to be worried about their whereabouts and how to retrive them.