Candidates in Washtenaw County spent thousands on campaigns, new finance reports show
(This story has been updated to reflect information from campaign finance reports filed by John Hieftje, Jack Eaton, Lou Glorie. Glorie filed her report late today. Eaton filed his report shortly before the county clerk's office closed on Thursday, but due to a lag on the county's part it was not posted online until today. Hieftje filed his report on time, but due to a technical glitch it was not posted correctly online.)
Post-primary campaign finance reports filed Thursday show candidates in Washtenaw County spent some serious money competing for party nominations in the Aug. 3 primary election.
By far the biggest battle was the 18th District state Senate race that pitted state Rep. Rebekah Warren, D-Ann Arbor, against state Rep. Pam Byrnes, D-Lyndon Township.
The two lawmakers combined to spend more than $380,000 on their campaigns — $198,529 spent by Byrnes and $181,631 spent by Warren.
Warren, who won the Democratic primary and now is highly favored to beat her Republican rival in November, raised $183,766, plus another $3,843 in in-kind contributions. Byrnes raised $212,233, plus $1,375 in in-kind contributions.
Reports show Warren contributed $19,000 of her own money to her campaign one day before the primary, bringing the total amount she spent out of her own pocket up to $29,175.
She also accepted money from several political action committees late in the campaign, including $5,000 from the UAW Michigan PAC and $2,000 from the Michigan Association for Justice. She also took $4,000 from the Michigan Beer and Wine Wholesalers Association and $1,000 from the Michigan Laborers Political League.
The latest reports show Byrnes received $5,000 from House Speaker Andy Dillon's Leadership Fund, $3,750 from the Michigan Beer and Wine Wholesalers Association, $500 from the Detroit Regional Chamber of Commerce and $500 from the Dow Corning Legislative Action Team.
Staebler vs. Irwin
In another heavily funded race, Ann Arbor's Ned Staebler amassed $100,534 in contributions in his unsuccessful bid for the 53rd District state House seat.
He lost in the Democratic primary to Washtenaw County Commissioner Jeff Irwin, also of Ann Arbor, who raised $47,035. Irwin is highly favored to beat his Republican rival in November and replace Warren in the state House.
Staebler reported $2,684 in in-kind contributions, while Irwin reported $5,112. Staebler ultimately spent $88,346, compared to the $45,266 spent by Irwin.
Reports filed Thursday show Staebler received a $5,000 boost to his campaign from the UAW Michigan PAC. He also took $2,500 from the Michigan Beer and Wine Wholesalers Association.
Irwin's largest contributions since his pre-primary statement filed in July include $250 from the Michigan Credit Union Action League and $250 from consultant Arthur Miller.
Ann Arbor mayoral race
Patricia Lesko raised and spent more than $6,700 — in addition to $1,116 in in-kind contributions — competing for the mayoral seat in Ann Arbor. She lost to incumbent Mayor John Hieftje, who now faces an independent challenger in November.
Lesko, as reported before the primary, also received a significant boost from the city's firefighters union, which spent $5,144 on billboards and T-shirts advertising her campaign.
Reports filed with the county clerk show Lesko donated $1,100 of her own money to her campaign two days before the primary, bringing the total amount of her own money spent up to $2,625. Hieftje had not used any of his own money in his campaign as of the last report.
Hieftje raised $12,575, plus $586 in in-kind contributions. He spent $14,237, including tapping into funds left over from a previous campaign.
He took $1,000 from the Michigan Regional Council of Carpenters and $500 from the UAW Michigan PAC. His reports also show somewhat of an oddity — a $6 donation from his campaign to the Ann Arbor-based nonprofit Ecology Center, accompanied by a letter from Heiftje's campaign treasurer, Leah Gunn.
Gunn acknowledged the campaign violated state law by accepting an anonymous $6 contribution, which she characterized as "money in the dish," and reporting it. The remedy for these types of situations, according to state law, is to donate the money to a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization, and Hieftje's campaign chose the Ecology Center.
"It was me entirely," Gunn said by phone, taking credit for the campaign finance violation. "I should have known better, but at least we did have a remedy."
Ann Arbor City Council
In three contested City Council races, the incumbents all went on to victory and spent thousands of dollars in the process.
In the 1st Ward race, Democratic incumbent Sandi Smith raised $3,930, compared to Democratic challenger Sumi Kailasapathy's $3,050.
Smith spent $3,806, and Kailasapathy spent $2,842. Smith reported another $289 in in-kind contributions, while Kailasapathy reported $66.
Smith received a $250 contribution two days before the election from the Michigan Laborers Political League PAC. She also accepted $100 from the Builders and Remodelers Association of Greater Ann Arbor.
In the 5th Ward race, Democratic incumbent Carsten Hohnke raised $6,772, plus another $476 in in-kind contributions.
Hohnke, who faces two challengers in November, spent $6,988 altogether, including money left over from a previous campaign, leaving a balance of $135 in his campaign fund.
Democratic challenger Lou Glorie did not file a post-primary report on Thursday. She paid a $25 fee when filing her report late today, showing she raised $2,835 (the same amount she reported in July), plus $249 in in-kind contributions. She spent $1,890.
In the 4th Ward race, Democratic incumbent Margie Teall raised $7,110 and spent $5,470. She reported another $75 in in-kind contributions.
Democratic challenger Jack Eaton raised $4,644 ($25 more than he reported in July), plus another $278 in in-kind contributions. He spent $3,810.
Michigan gubernatorial race
Ann Arbor businessman Rick Snyder spent $7.6 million to win the GOP nomination in the Michigan gubernatorial race — more than double that of Attorney General Mike Cox, who raised and spent about $3.3 million.
Oakland County Sheriff Mike Bouchard spent $2.2 million, and U.S. Rep. Pete Hoekstra, R-Holland, spent $1.8 million. State Sen. Tom George of Kalamazoo spent more than $400,000.
Democratic gubernatorial candidate Virg Bernero tapped public campaign funds and raised private contributions to win the Democratic primary. Bernero accepted $111,902 in public funding and raised $1.03 million in contributions, according to reports filed Thursday.
House Speaker Andy Dillon, who was defeated by Bernero in the Democratic primary, raised just over $1.8 million.
Bernero also has accepted the full $1.125 million he's eligible for from the state for his general election campaign.
Ryan J. Stanton covers government and politics for AnnArbor.com. Reach him at ryanstanton@annarbor.com or 734-623-2529.
Comments
Roadman
Mon, Sep 6, 2010 : 10:24 p.m.
Arthur Miller was former Michigan Senate Minority Leader before retiring and going into consulting and lobbying work. He served with Jeff Irwin's father in the Michigan Legislature. State Senator Tom George was a political gadfly who had to fight to get his way into debates as he had almost no chance of winning. Kinda like a Tom Partridge in the governor's race.
Speechless
Sat, Sep 4, 2010 : 1:10 p.m.
Snyder has also accepted the full $7.6 million he's donated to his own campaign. He will use that money to purchase the election fair and square. Can't let those dollars go toward helping the state budget, can we now?
Lokalisierung
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 5:35 p.m.
"Of course. Can't let those tax dollars help the budget, can we now?" Egads! Someone is using the money they're "eligiable" for? I guess I'll just be mad ay anyoine for spending any money at all instead of donating it to the states coffers eh?
John of Saline
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 5:24 p.m.
Bernero also has accepted the full $1.125 million he's eligible for from the state for his general election campaign. Of course. Can't let those tax dollars help the budget, can we now?
David Cahill
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 4:10 p.m.
I think there is a technical problem with the online version of Mayor Hieftje's report. The contribution pages are there, but the expenditure pages are not.
Barb
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 2:19 p.m.
The comments and updates needed to this, the lead story today, are unbelievable. Unbelievable.
Matt Yankee
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 1:28 p.m.
You're welcome, Ryan. It's important to realize that unlike the State which utilizes electronic filings allowing for (what I suspect is) fairly instantaneous access to reports, the Countys database is all maintained manually by hand. There is no automated process to scan documents, upload them to our server, and then add them to the database it all must be done step by step with our limited staffing resources. And even then, the information was all available online by 10AM today. The database is provided as an extra service to County residents to make campaign finance filings more transparent; however, for completely up-to-date records, I would always recommend confirming the information with our office.
Ryan J. Stanton
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 12:46 p.m.
@Matt and Jack Thanks for the info. I am updating the story now and will clarify what happened in both cases. It's good to know about these types of potential glitches for future reference, so I appreciate you bringing it to my attention.
Matt Yankee
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 11:58 a.m.
John Hieftje submitted his report on time; on August 30, 2010 in fact. The County's Campaign Finance database has a slight glitch where, at times, a newly scanned report will not display at the bottom document list, but rather somewhere in the middle of the list. It is important to scan through a candidate's entire list of documents before assuming the report was not filed until the glitch can be identified and fixed. In this case, the report in question is 4th from the bottom. For those curious, here is a direct link to the report in PDF format: https://secure.ewashtenaw.org/campaignfinance/userViewFile.do?filename=%2FPDF%2FC-2000-0510048.pdf
Jack Eaton
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 10:32 a.m.
The article states: "Democratic challenger Jack Eaton, who had raised $4,619 as of his pre-primary report in July, did not file a post-primary report." In fact, I submitted my finance report in person on Thursday afternoon. A simple telephone call to the county elections clerk this morning confirmed that they had received the report. They had not yet scanned and posted my report, but it was timely filed. Does anyone fact check these articles before they are posted?
just a voice
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 10:06 a.m.
ryan, give us some perspective please, can we compare these numbers to other similar states so we know if we spent more or less. Also wondering on how many campaigns like Irwin won while being outspent 2 to 1 by thier opponent. Is that rare *assuming no incumbent
David Cahill
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 8:38 a.m.
It's good to see this kind of follow-up coverage. Where else would we be told about the link between the failed campaigns of Dillon and Byrnes, or would we learn that Warren spent nearly $30,000 on her bid? I am also concerned that Mayor Hieftje has failed to file the required report. I think there is a "late filing fee" of $25.00 per day. Ryan, can you help us out on this?
AlwaysLate
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 8:16 a.m.
Agreed...if this is a story at all, it should be exploring why Hieftje missed the reporting deadline. Is reporting required by law? If so, what is the penalty? If not, it's a non-non-story.
Forever27
Fri, Sep 3, 2010 : 7:37 a.m.
This is a non-story. Campaigns cost money.