Ann Arbor Summer Festival 2012 reports good attendance, no rainouts, and contribution shortfall
The Top of the Park crowd on the last night of this year's Ann Arbor Summer Festival on Ingalls Mall.
Jeffrey Smith | AnnArbor.com
“It’s always something - last year, I kept losing my credentials,” said Woulfe. “So (the staff) made me four sets of credentials this year. I’m like a kid with mittens.”
Such minor oversights seem easy to forgive, given how many events Woulfe plans and oversees during the three-week annual Festival, which this year included: twelve mainstage, paid-ticket events, including concert performances by Bonnie Raitt, Al Green and Rufus Wainwright; thirteen free outdoor movies; a few dozen free live music shows on two outdoor stages (The Grove and The Rackham Stage); and a variety of free community programs, ranging from yoga to a trivia contest to a dinosaur petting zoo, presented by Australia’s Erth-Visual and Physical, Inc.
“There’s nothing like watching several hundred children lose their mind when a T-Rex appears from behind a white tent,” said Woulfe.
Revenue accrued from mainstage events ($800,246 this year, up from $533,300 last year), as well as Top of the Park beverage and merchandise sales ($204,229 this year, up from $185,603 last year), was solid, but on-site donations were down, leaving A2SF with a fundraising gap to fill between now and the end of September, the end of its fiscal year.
Last year, A2SF raised $60,138 through its “Give 3” on-site campaign at TOP, but attendees reported that the fundraising seemed too invasive and “hard sell.” In response, A2SF altered its strategy and “softened” its sell this year, and contributions totaled $51,250.
“We didn't want the festival-going experience to feel like a constant pledge drive, or for guests to feel overly interrupted by the volunteer collectors, but this less amplified messaging seems to have lessened our return,” said Woulfe.
Indeed, Woulfe and his team budgeted for $65,000 in on-site contributions this year, leading to A2SF’s current $15,000 shortfall in this area. (A2SF now needs to raise a total of $45,000-$50,000 by September's end.)
“A lot of times, people have a great time at the Festival and generously send a donation afterward,” said Woulfe. “ So I’m not overly concerned, but it’s important that those gifts come in.”
The mainstage series had three sellout events (Ira Glass, Pilobolus, and The Moth Mainstage), but others underperformed.
Nellie McKay was new to the Festival, and sold “more seats than we thought she would,” said Woulfe. “But when you put an intimate jazz cabaret artist in a big venue, that can be challenging. And Cinematic Titanic - when we had them before, they sold out two shows, and that didn't happen this time around. But the 4th being in the middle of the week affected things in strange ways. On the 4th we had huge crowds at Top of the Park, but some indoor events around that time frame didn’t fare as well. So that was a little bit surprising.”
Of course, A2SF also contended with thirteen days of ninety-plus degree temperatures (four of which reached more than 100 degrees).
Even so, “I will take the heat over the rain any day,” said Woulfe. “ The good thing about heat is people can always find a place under the trees have a drink. And we had zero rainouts. Yes, there were some sunshowers, five or ten minute rainshowers, but all the bands got up, and all the movies got up. Usually we have two to three full rainouts.”
So although the extreme temperatures may have kept some people away in the fest’s final days, turnouts were high during A2SF’s first two weeks, and Woulfe generally feels satisfied and happy with the way things unfolded. (You can see local photographer Myra Klarman's photos from this year's A2SF here.)
Not that Woulfe’s relaxing too much. Now’s the time when he and his team look at the numbers, read the feedback, raise money, and begin planning for next year.
“The biggest challenge for us is that people think that the season’s over, and that it was so successful that they don’t need to give, but fundraising is ongoing always,” said Woulfe. “We hope that if people had a good time, they’ll show their support.”
Jenn McKee is the entertainment digital journalist for AnnArbor.com. Reach her at jennmckee@annarbor.com or 734-623-2546, and follow her on Twitter @jennmckee.
Comments
John Hritz
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 8:49 p.m.
Perhaps I'm greedy, but I don't feel like paying an additional $3/head on nights when I've already paid for main stage tickets and I still think the collections process is too intrusive. The Give 3 promotion is a contradiction. It is more explicit than the old "help keep the lights on" campaign, but also sets an upper bound for a donation. A better way might be to have both a method to make small cash donations and on-the-spot more substantial donations. A group of people with iPads and Square payment card readers could take larger donations and email receipts for tax purposes. https://squareup.com/pay-with-square The quality of Top of the Park sells itself. It is as a yearly event that many people look forward to. Lets make it easier for people to do the right thing and avoid anchoring them at $3.
Top Cat
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 2:24 p.m.
People would be as willing to pay $5 a head as they would $3. The music and people watching are well worth it.
Birddive
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 2:07 p.m.
I'm with Ross. Tickets for most of the mainstage events were too expensive for many people I know who wanted to attend. If revenue from mainstage events, beverages and merchandise sales was up a total of $285,572, but on-site donations were down $8,888, that stills leaves a total revenue increase of $276,684 over last year. There must be something I'm not understanding. Why the need for more fundraiser?
Jenn McKee
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 4:37 p.m.
Here's a response from Robb Woulfe: "The cost of producing this year's Mainstage season (artist fees, stage labor, venue rentals, production costs, etc.) was significantly higher than last season. Also, the revenue jump is due to the number of tickets sold to Mainstage events -- 17,517 tickets sold in 2012 versus 12,011 tickets sold in 2011 -- as the this season's average ticket price was actually lower than last year ($43.23 in 2012 vs. $45.21 in 2011).
Ross
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 1:14 p.m.
Wow, mainstage revenue up to 800k from 533k last year (with comparable event quality) ?!? Rob, please lower the ticket prices for 2013. This year was a real raking over the coals.
jns131
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 1:09 p.m.
Some day I might go. But it is the parking that makes me stay away from Ann Arbor. The last time I went? I paid $10 at a parking structure. No thanks. Glad to hear it was a success.
JanS
Thu, Jul 12, 2012 : 2:05 a.m.
Jessica, Tally Hall structure is now called Liberty Square and the flat rate is $3. Still a bargain for the entire evening.
Jessica Webster
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 2:51 p.m.
You sure you paid $10? Both garages that flank the TOP only charged $5. And if you head down a little on Washington, I believe the Tally Hall structure is a flat $2 in the evenings.
say it plain
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 2:13 p.m.
@Ross is right...if you're willing to walk a couple blocks, there is *always* parking near downtown for free! Well, football saturdays can be a nightmare, but for everything else, literally everything else, including summer festival and art fair, a nice walk is all that's needed! At least for now...we'll see how things play out when all the new 'density' towers get filled out in and near downtown...
Ross
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 1:15 p.m.
You need to get a little more savvy. I always park for free just by walking a few blocks. Or there is the flat rate $3 lot on washington.
James
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 1:06 p.m.
$5 corona's is contributing
BHospadaruk
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 2:15 p.m.
Sorry, but that isn't contributing to the cost do the festival, have you been to a Tiger game lately, beer is $9.50, a ticket costs $15-75 and that does not count the cost of gas to get there.
David Johnson
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 12:23 p.m.
My family and I moved to Ann Arbor in March. This is our first summer experiencing all of the festivals. We went downtown 5 evenings and enjoyed each of them! We saw GhostBusters and Lebowski, we danced to great music, and got our bearings about us when being downtown. Each time we went, we dropped 5 dollars in the collection tubes. We continuously tell our friends and family how happy we are to be here, and the Summer Festival is a large reason why. So far, awesome!
Ross
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 1:16 p.m.
Awesome! Welcome to town. Pretty fun, eh? Get ready (to avoid) the art fair!! J/k, you gotta check it out, as some townie newbs.
brimble
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 11:56 a.m.
Year over year, this event successfully draws people to the downtown/campus area, where the enjoy themselves and spend money, then go home with a positive feeling about being in downtown Ann Arbor. Good thing the Downtown Development Authority can just sit back and take credit. Please do support the A2SF (they don't have our tax dollars), so that they can be back next year!
Madeleine Borthwick
Wed, Jul 11, 2012 : 1:19 p.m.
yeah brimble, the DDA is good at patting themselves on the back whether they actually deserve it or not.