Unnamed buyer to purchase 233 foreclosed condos at Woodland Mews in Ann Arbor
A troubled condo complex in the city of Ann Arbor that never completed its conversion from apartments will have a new owner by year-end.
Woodlands Mews was listed for sale after the lender - originally LaSalle Bank, then Bank of America - took the property through foreclosure on a $31.8 million debt.
Now, said listing agent Mark Rohr of Hendricks & Partners of Birmingham, a buyer is negotiating a purchase agreement after bids were sought through Oct 1.
“There was quite a bit of interest,” Rohr said, from a mix of national and regional buyers.But it also was a property where the strong positives were balanced with a rare negative: The location and size of the units create opportunity at foreclosure pricing; the condo aspects- described by Rohr as “broken” - make it difficult, if not impossible, to finance.
The entire complex is 306 units - and it formerly was known as Woodland Meadows. It’s located between Ann Arbor-Saline Road and South Main Street, south of Woodland Plaza shopping center.
The property had been owned by Sam Zell’s Equity Residential before Zell decided to exit Michigan in 2005.
A division of Chicago-based Northern Realty Group Ltd. Bought the property from Equity Residential in early 2006.
That deal shows the transition in Ann Arbor’s commercial real estate market.
The purchase price in 2006 was $40.49 million, or $130,000 per unit - the highest per-unit deal recorded in Washtenaw County.
The reason Northern Realty paid that price was its intent to convert the property to condominiums - meaning that the price per unit, normally part of a measure for determining payback on rental income, just set the bar for individual unit sales as condos. They could pay more than market rate for apartments, they said.
The style of units lent themselves to that, the buyers told me at the time: there were 138 townhouses of more than 2,000 square feet with garages, and 168 flats with large floorplans. The setting, 24 acres with a small lake and parkland, was attractive for residents.
And in early 2006, the condo market in Ann Arbor didn’t offer much beneath that $130,000 threshold.
That changed, of course.
As the units in Woodland Meadows were converted into condos and renamed Woodland Mews, many units in many of the buildings found buyers as the rentals “turned over.”
But the market was collapsing and the owner ended up with an effective patchwork among the buildings - some were owned privately, some were still rented - and of those unsold, all were owned by the buyer.
By the time the property went into foreclosure, 73 condos were privately owned. They still are - the buyer of the complex only acquires the 233 unsold units.
There was no advertised pricing for the foreclosure sale - potential buyers submitted bids. Sources say the final purchase price is likely to be in the $16- to $17-million range.
Meanwhile, the condos that sold to individual buyers have fallen in value due to the inability of buyers to get financing for the condos due to the poor fundamentals. While listings have been in the $125,000 range, one is now on the market for under $70,000, the owners likely hoping for cash buyers.
Rohr said the property remains a strong piece of real estate as a rental property for the new owner. The average rental income from the unsold condos was $1,247 per month.
“This will be an excellent opportunity,” Rohr said. “Everyone’s excited about the opportunity to clean this deal up and get it back on track.”
Individual owners of the condos also are likely to value the sale, despite the fact that they’ll own units in what will remain a rental property for quite some time. The property, under the care of a receiver for almost 3 years, didn’t thrive.
The sale, Rohr said, means “that finally someone is going to take care of the place.”
Paula Gardner is Business News Director of AnnArbor.com. Contact her at 734-623-2586 or by email. Sign up for the weekly Business Review newsletter, distributed every Thursday, here.<
Comments
A2girl7
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 10:11 p.m.
A2 lover you hit the nail on the head. Sad thing is mr tobin walked away without ever being held accountable, I guess that's what an LLC means these days!
Vivienne Armentrout
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 3:01 p.m.
This is a tragic story (though I hope the recent news is good). A thriving multifamily community in a good location has been compromised by the attempted condo conversion. It was a valuable addition to our housing supply and I hope that it can be brought back into a stable condition. It is worth noting that Sam Zell is a takeover king - the very one who led a buyout of the Chicago Tribune. He thus placed a huge debt load on that important news organization and it is struggling.
A2lover
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 1:59 p.m.
I'm sure the original buyers thought that all the units in the entire property, in a good location (even moreso now Wholefoods is in walking distance) would sell, and would become a legitimate condominium complex. Sounds like the Chicago buyer was a bit of a shyster, and when it appeared that the majority of the units were not selling, just took off. Probably with the original association fees.
Mick52
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 11:57 a.m.
Interesting article. I have a question. Typically in a condo development, there is an association fee. Is this in place here? Do renters have to pay it too? Oops, that is two questions. One thing about buying a condo in a development like this is that if many become vacant, the assoc fees cannot cover maintenance and it is up to the owners to fund basic maintenance. Who would buy a condo in a development that is having fiscal difficulties?
VectorKyam
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 11:45 a.m.
Just try to get financing to buy one of those units now, and any individuals will soon find out that their only option will probably to pay cash for it. FHA or even a conventional mortgage will be out of the question.
halflight
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 9:08 a.m.
I'll second Ms. Gardner's account. The rental units became condominium units when the owner/developer filed a condominium master deed with the Register of Deeds. No rental units could be sold as separate parcels before the owner/developer filed a master deed. The owner/developer can lease individual condominium units to tenants until they are sold to co-owners, and (depending on the terms of the master deed) individual co-owners may lease their units to tenants.
Paula Gardner
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 7:38 a.m.
They are being operated as rental units - but each unit has been "split" into its own condominium with a separate tax ID number, taxable value, etc.
Go Blue
Thu, Oct 21, 2010 : 7:04 a.m.
'Unnamed buyer to purchase......' The sale/purchase covers rental units not condos. The condos are privately owned as mentioned in the article. Foreclosure covered the rental apartments and townhomes that were not converted. May be helpful to clarify.